Editor's note - Ingar is also responding to a question I
8-bit MCUs in a recent edition of the Focus on MCU newsletter: "What
are your thoughts on 8-bit versus 16-bit versus 32-bit MCUs?"
Why is everybody talking about the CPU? In our experience,
microcontrollers are chosen by their feature set and if they meet the
application requirements, not by the width of the CPU instruction. The
basic question is: Does the MCU have the correct peripheral set for the
application? Does it meet cost and power constraints?
Part of the drive to 32-bit CPUs can be explained by the fact that
applications need more peripherals. Processing peripherals requires
interrupts, each of which requires many MIPS to service. In many
instances, the computational load can be met easily by an 8-bit CPU.
The extra MIPS are required for interrupt processing, not computation.
C-friendly, RISC 8-bit CPUs, like the AVR, solve the shortcomings of
traditional 8-bit CPUs with a linear address space, single-cycle
instructions, a 32-byte register file where all registers acts as
accumulators. AVR XMEGA solves the interrupt issue by off-loading
peripheral-to-peripheral communications to an event manager with DMA.
It literally eliminates interrupts altogether, improving response times
and cutting power consumption.
I have still not seen a market analysis that has a larger 32-bit than
8-bit microcontroller market in its forecast. 32-bits are the fastest
growing, but 8-bit still enjoy more than 40% market share and will
continue to do so in the foreseeable future. This is measuring in
dollar revenue shipped. Looking at units shipped, 8-bit market share is
If given a choice, I think many designers would prefer to stick with
their 8-bit devices, as long as they can get the peripheral set and
performance they need. The success and fast growth of the AVR product
line is strong evidence that 8-bit MCUs are not going to be replaced
any time soon.
Join our online Radio Show on Friday 11th July starting at 2:00pm Eastern, when EETimes editor of all things fun and interesting, Max Maxfield, and embedded systems expert, Jack Ganssle, will debate as to just what is, and is not, and embedded system.