Let me just start off with a tiny bit of background. The first thought that many people will have when reading that headline is that I must be some kind of Apple fan-boy. I would counter that with some personal history.
I love Linux. Or rather, I love Linux in certain situations. I've used it quite extensively for years, both in desktop and server functions. I've built web servers, mail servers, DNS servers, and file storage. I've waded through the dependency tangles on the desktop and fought to get the wireless working on many many laptops. (Remember the Broadcom wrapper installation procedure? I do.) When I had a web design studio, I used Linux exclusively on my machines for roughly a year.
However, I found that when it came to daily functional use, I was spending more time making the system work than I was working at the system. With Linux, I always had some issue for which I would have to find a workaround. Ultimately, I decided that unless I was putting together a purpose-built server, I was wasting too much time tinkering with the OS.
When Android surfaced, I saw a brilliant opportunity for purpose-built devices on open-source software to excel and kick some serious butt. I ran out and bought a Nook Color and rooted it. After a week or two of playing with it, I was again finding that I spent more time getting it to work than I did actually getting to use it.
I figured it was probably just because this device wasn't intended to be used with stock Android. I had rooted it, after all. On top of that, I found the applications for the device to be all over the place in terms of quality or function, or even resolution (more on this later). I found very similar experiences with the handful of Android devices I had to support while I was an IT administrator for several years.
Around this time, I bought a first generation, used iPad for my kids to play with. It has functioned completely flawlessly and still does to this day. Every "app" I buy for it functions as advertised, and they are all designed for this exact piece of hardware, though I understand it is possible to run iPhone apps on the device. I have had zero hardware bugs.
I recently found myself in need of a portable system for writing while I travel, so I started shopping around. I was immediately drawn to the the Nexus7 v2. This thing is a piece of beauty with its amazingly high-resolution screen, thin and light construction, and fantastic battery. Google has put a lot of work into the Play store in the last couple years, which really gave me hope for the application issues. I bought one and did it happily. That part of me that hates being mainstream rejoiced in the ability to figuratively give the finger to the big evil corporation of Apple.
Today, I'm returning it and getting an iPad. No single issue has led me to this point, but rather, a collection of small annoyances has outweighed my desire to have an Android device.
1. Bluetooth is broken.
My intention was to buy a tablet for writing while I travel. I imagined myself propping this thing up in an airport or hotel room, connecting my Bluetooth keyboard, and typing away happily. Unfortunately, what I found was that Android 4.3 (what comes on the Nexus7), has an issue rendering most Bluetooth keyboards completely incapable of functioning.
I couldn't believe it. This seems like it would be a really big deal, but it is yet unresolved. A quick Google search finds that I'm not alone in this. You begin typing and the keyboard goes nuts repeating characters until it decides to stop.
2. Applications suffering from hardware fragmentation.
Google has worked really hard on the play store. I booted it up and it looked fantastic. Things were clearly labelled and buying things was fantastically easy. However, I still found that some applications were just the cellphone versions scaled up. While it doesn't take much effort to uninstall a cruddy app and hunt down another, it is still incredibly annoying. I also downloaded a couple games that crashed when I attempted to run them. I understand that this is because tons of Android devices are out there and it is impossible to build software that will work flawlessly on all of them.
3. Bugginess in both the OS and the applications
This is the biggest annoyance. The touchscreen has decided to become unresponsive at least once a day since I bought it. It will be working fine, but then suddenly finger touches don't count. I have to hold my finger in place for a second for it to register, then sometimes it will register it as multiple touches. A quick reboot fixes the problem, but that is a pain in the butt when you're trying to carry out a task.
When the tablet reboots, it goes through the process of bringing up the lock screen. I don't know about the others out there, but mine does not cleanly transition from boot sequence to lock screen, there is a flickery mess that happens. This is in no way hindering me from carrying out a task, but rather is just another notch in the "this doesn't feel completed" column.
I realize that this isn't necessarily the fault of Android, but my Netflix application has become completely unresponsive several times in the past two weeks. I have uninstalled it and re-installed it, which fixed the issue (twice). Again, not a show stopper, but a pain in the butt. Did I mention that you can't watch Amazon streaming video on it? Well, theoretically you can if you root it and install some unsupported software (which still didn't work on mine), but out of the box you can'y.
I am hoping that I got a lemon. I've owned this thing roughly two weeks and I now have a nasty dead column in the middle of my screen. It isn't completely dead, it inverts colors from elsewhere. If it had worked flawlessly for a year I could almost overlook something like this, but it is two weeks old and already carrying the baggage of the annoyances listed above.
I actually want to love this thing. It is sleek, feels good in my hand, and has a vivid and colorful screen. The sound quality is good, the battery is good, and Android is so close to being something I would hand to my grandmother with confidence. When applications work they are fast, and there's no lag in navigation at all. If I were one of those guys who had to write a review after an hour of hands-on time, I'd be gushing over this thing.
However, I'm faced with the following issues right now:
I can't work on it (I'm not writing a 1,000 word article with the admittedly nice on screen keyboard).
I can't count on it to work correctly when I pick it up.
I really hope that Google digs in and refines this product. I would love to see even half of these problems worked out. I've decided that I'm not in the market for a "fixer upper" right now. I need a device that will actually just do these things. I'll get an iPad and just accept that maybe I'm not one of the cool kids (in my crowd at least).
Totally agree about wanting cross-platform functionality. For me this involves using Dropbox and working in Markdown/HTML almost exclusively. On that note, as a "power user" interested in using the iPad as a writing platform, you may want to check out the recently released Editorial app. It offers powerful automation capabilities not previously available in iOS text editors. For more (much more!), see this extensive review.
Notes Plus is great (as is its optional handwriting-to-text feature), but it wouldn't be my first choice for a primary writing/editing platform on the iPad. See my other reply in this thread for some thoughts on that.
I still use my BlackBerry Playbook every day and it's great for travel.
Unfortunately it was a flop in the marketplace, but is still a great tablet for many purposes. No Netflix, but Amazon Video works fine as does loading up your own ripped movies, which is what I usually do.
The Mini Keyboard with Trackpad is a pretty good Blue Tooth accessory, although many other mice and keyboards work too.
1. The point was vacation, not work travel. Your spouse and children may accompany you on you work travel, but you're working, and then you'd need to worry about what they will do while you are working.
2. No, I knew the OP was talking about downtime, not for the purpose of main attraction. That is why I gave the example of skiiing/snowboarding at night. We also do hike camps where the extra tech is too heavy, only the phones go for emergency use.
I think I'm pretty fair at vacation planning, but I won't try to either dazzle you or bore you with the details. There's still downtime and movies are a good way of filling it. I'm not saying that it ruins the vacation. And there's always Skymall on the plane. I'm talking about how competing LUXURIES, not necessities, compare. I'm sure we'd all get along just fine if the tablet market had never gotten past the Newton, but that's not really the point.
1. I bought a tablet for work travel. Not necessarily vacation, however having the ability to be connected easier and more frequently actually allow me to take more time off. I can work from the road now!
2. I don't think anyone here was suggesting that they were going to be glued to a device for the entirety of a vacation. That is just being silly.
Wife and kids not having the movie they want on vacation? You're a poor vacation planner. Have you ever tried just talking to each other to remain connected? Share new experiences (e.g. skiing, snowboarding at night for winter; surfing at night for summer), not watch a movie. So, you do things on vacation that you'd do at home; although not really relaxing, a staycation could be a lot cheaper and no issue with not having the movie they want.
I know this is about dumping the Nexus 7 and buyng an iPad, but how about leaving your devices all at home when you're on vacation? I've done that before, that is really relaxing, and no chance of anyone at work calling with an "emergency" like running out of toner (I don't handle that in our office, but often they think that since I am IT, that I know about "these things" - no, I don't know where the coffee filters are). What if you want to find something, have you lost your ability to ask?
"Admittedly, the mini is probably a decent size, but then would that really exist in a world without Android tablet "fragmentation"?"
Probably, the newton (apples first jump into tablets) was roughly 7 inches before android existed. It didn't live long, but they were already contemplating optimal size for a handheld computing device.