Breaking News
Blog

What Venture Capitalists Want: Engineers' Guide to Researching Business Opportunities

NO RATINGS
4 saves
Page 1 / 2 Next >
View Comments: Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
Michel Courtoy
User Rank
Author
Re: What Venture Capitalists Want...
Michel Courtoy   4/11/2014 1:38:38 PM
NO RATINGS
Hello Barun,

 

Thanks for your feedback.  I reached the very similar conclusion that you outlined: the lack of VC funding needs to be compensated by other creative funding sources.  The strategic partners appear as the most likely target.  In my mind, it is the completion of the 'circle of innovation'.  Let me explain briefly in the context of EDA.  No VC means no new technology, so the customers (semis) are starved for innovation, the smart ones will start investing strategically in companies that provide the new technologies they need to create their products.

The flipside is that semi companies sometimes choose to invest into internal development rather than fund promising start-ups.  It is happening right now in some of the major semis.  It is the traditional 'make vs buy' turned into make internally vs make externally'.

Best regards,


Michel

barunkd
User Rank
Author
Re: What Venture Capitalists Want...
barunkd   4/11/2014 5:30:44 AM
NO RATINGS
Hi Micael,

I think the issue is not availability of fund, issue is understanding semi/ EDA business and creating a sustainable RoI model. Major reasons why a VC does not fund in semi/ EDA start-up

1. High fund requirement: May not be true for EDA or IP strat-up, but true for fabless strat-up

2. Longer return time: Any semi/ EDA company takes at least 2 - 3 years (for fabless it is more) to strat earning decent revenue. VCs whose typical investment horizon is 3 - 5 years this is a long duration

3. Absence of tangible asset: The asset created by semi/ EDA company is intangible in nature, if the company is not able to earn revenue or not able to see enough customer traction the exit value is very small

4. Lack of understanding: Good number of VCs does not understand the high tech market very well and they are reluctant to invest

Let us see how these problems can be addressed

1. Creation of strategic investors: A strategic investor is a person/ company who is not only investing in the start-up, but also is a potential customer/ acquirer of the product. In that scenario, his return from the investment goes beyond the cash he received by selling his equity in the start-up. A start-up in semi/ EDA will always look for such investor. Also the big companies who are hungry for new technology to survive create a dedicated fund for start-ups whose technology is relevant to his line of business

2. Equity in exchange of services/ tools: A start-up needs to drive down the cost and should be ready to give up some equity in exchange of services/ tools he needs. For example an IP company can give some equity to an EDA company to get access to the EDA tool. A fabless company can negotiate with a design services company to get design services in exchange of equity. Off course EDA and design services company should also be prepared for that

Regards,

Barun

 

 

 

Michel Courtoy
User Rank
Author
Re: What Venture Capitalists Want...
Michel Courtoy   8/30/2013 4:51:45 PM
NO RATINGS
Agreed: there are two ways EDA can expand beyond its present mature 'perimeter'.  First, get into new markets: software development is an often mentioned candidate; new applications such as wearable devices - as you suggest - might be another opportunity.  The other key is revamping the business model: EDA 's market size is 1-2% of the semiconductor industry!  Clearly EDA is not extracting value from its technology.  Cloud offerings might help; more solutions oriented delivery (srevices?) have worked in some cases.

 

docdivakar
User Rank
Author
Re: What Venture Capitalists Want...
docdivakar   8/29/2013 4:14:15 PM
NO RATINGS
@Michel: I appreciate your candor and the follow up. EDA market in my opinion has attained a high level of maturity and there are only few new product options (other than IP). I think the EDA industry, in order to keep innovative enterprises thriving, has to offer many more solutions than the current generation legacy ones. This is easier said than done but the evolving trends are clearly visible -to cite a few examples, wearable devices, products made with molded interconnect devices (which can be printed with 3D printers), etc. Some of these newer markets that can be easily addressed by EDA companies are not done so because the product pricing and positioning conflicts with existing models.

MP Divakar

Michel Courtoy
User Rank
Author
Re: What Venture Capitalists Want...
Michel Courtoy   8/29/2013 3:11:03 PM
NO RATINGS
MP - Fully agreed about the bleak VC funding environment for semi/EDA.  I commented about this in a previous blog, 'Improving the EDA funding environment' (7/23/2013).  I believe that for EDA the early stages have to covered by angels and 'sweat equity' from the founding team.  The process I propose applies to the angels interaction.

The crowdfunding is very interesting but appears to be catching on when the funder is a potential consumer or has some other affinity with the product.  This crowd is limited with semi/EDA and reduces itself mostly to angels who have been involved in the industry - either as producers or consumers.

docdivakar
User Rank
Author
Re: What Venture Capitalists Want...
docdivakar   8/28/2013 10:09:26 PM
NO RATINGS
The article is entirely VC-centric and from what I gather, it does not look too encouraging for new hardware startups. On the contrary, look at what is happening in the wearables market including Quantified Self -an majority of the startups in this area have been crowdfunded. Perhaps the author can comment on the subtle and/or direct differences in how a startup team can pitch to crowdfunding sources?

MP Divakar

Michel Courtoy
User Rank
Author
Re: What VCs want
Michel Courtoy   8/27/2013 2:54:47 PM
NO RATINGS
As you point out, the key to maintaining leadership is to create a culture of innovation.  Add to this retention and motivation of the good people.  

The VC's were - past tense since there are few left in semi - making a bet on one chip: get it right and you make a lot of money, acquisition or IPO ensues and the VC's gets out.  So the VC's were making a bet there would be a large market for the chip 2-3 years (the IC design cycle) ahead.  Tough call for a concept that is really innovative and requires at least a $20M investment.

Semi business model is inherently scalable, the main caveat to this would be if a heavy dose of services is required for 'design-in' of the new chip.

eewiz
User Rank
Author
What VCs want
eewiz   8/27/2013 2:23:28 AM
NO RATINGS
Interesting article Michel. May be you can be a bit more specific about semi/hardware startups.

Fo eg
  1. Can you maintain a sustainable, differentiated positioning?

In the case of semi industry, the only thing you can say to a VC is that you will keep on innovating. Any differentiation is temporary and competition will catch up. Is that enough?
  1. Is the business model scalable?

In most cases, that is a yes for semi/ee startup!

 

 

More Blogs
The field programmable analog array (FPAA) when it was first offered to the market about 15 years ago did not seem to capture the imagination the way the field-programmable gate array (FPGA) had done before it.
Spending a ton of money on R&D doesn’t guarantee successful new products. It takes leadership and an understanding of your markets.
Semiconductors are pivoting again, and the space is exploding.
What has NASA in store for the future of space exploration? Sister publication EDN celebrates its 60 years by looking forward to NASA's next.
Ford CEO revealed its decision to go for fully automated, look-ma-no-hands cars from the get-go, and its lofty vision to play a role in the transformation of personal transportation.

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed