Breaking News
Nice Circuit, Ugly Schematic
10/21/2013

This circuit, from a 1992 EDN Design Idea, measures alternating current or voltage and transmits the results on a 4- to 20-mA current loop.
This circuit, from a 1992 EDN Design Idea, measures alternating current or voltage and transmits the results on a 4- to 20-mA current loop.

Return to Article

View Comments: Oldest First | Newest First | Threaded View
Page 1 / 4   >   >>
dt_hayden
User Rank
CEO
Schematic styles
dt_hayden   10/21/2013 2:45:12 PM
NO RATINGS
Schematic styles are always an interesting thing to observe.  Do you try and fit it all on 1 page or spread it among several pages where signal flow is not as easy to follow?  Do you keep it architecturally flat or use the logical, but hard to follow, hierarchical design?   Do you place critical components like decoupling capacitors near their respective integrated circuits, or show them all in a common area connected to supply rail?  Do you make it clean looking by using wire stubs with node names for virtual connections, or make it easier to follow by showing complete lines of connectivity?  Do you use descriptive net names to aid in understanding, communicating, and documenting degugging efforts?  Do you include net name locators for on-sheet of off-sheet connections, or leave the user to search the schemtic to find them?  How do you deal with multiple grounds?

One general observation I have made over the years is the folks responsible for implementing and debugging systems have a drastically different approach from folks whose primary design responsibility is ASICs or FPGAs.

 

Caleb Kraft
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Schematic styles
Caleb Kraft   10/21/2013 3:11:37 PM
NO RATINGS
great, another aspect of design that I can do poorly!

David Ashton
User Rank
Blogger
Schematics
David Ashton   10/21/2013 3:45:55 PM
NO RATINGS
HI Bill.  I loved the old transistor radio schematic (being British by extraction I still prefer Circuit Diagram even though it takes longer to say and write).  Obviously from a coil manufacturer trying to sell his wares (note the list of trnasistor types you can use at the bottom!)

I think the nice thing about diagrams like this is that you have the power rails running along the top and the bottom and it's obvious what they are.  Looking at the EDN one, one IC is supplying the other two ICs but It takes a bit of examination to find this.

The worst as you say are MCU diagrams where the tendency seems to be to put ICs in isolation with a funny shaped box on each pin with a cryptic signal name in each.  Somewhere on the rest of the diagram is another box, going into another IC, with the same signal name.  Look, Ma, no wires! :-)     But to be fair some of those circuits would be very difficult to draw without looking like spaghetti.

I recently had to trace the circuit of a drill charger from its PCB.  I ended up with a real rats nest on a piece of paper.  I managed to draw it properly with only 2 crossovers.   It made it obvious how the circuit worked. and I  found the tidying-up process very satisfying.

 

 

Bert22306
User Rank
CEO
Crictui diagrams are another art form
Bert22306   10/21/2013 4:16:38 PM
NO RATINGS
They have to look good, for heaven's sake, like any other art form. In the tube days, the tubes were often lined up on top, and all the passive components feeding them underneath. In the early transistor days, I noticed the same drawing style. But now, and I think for good reason, the active components are not typically separated.

There's nothing like a well executed, complementary symmetry analog circuit diagram, NPN on top, PNP on bottom, IMO. I like the power supply bypass capacitors to be shown close to the component they are bypassing for. And yes, chips tend to not have their inner workings show, because aside from the simplest of chips, that would be practically impossible.

_hm
User Rank
CEO
needs notes and some values
_hm   10/21/2013 6:13:42 PM
NO RATINGS
If schematic is annotated with some notes and few caluculated values, it is further helpful to many people for future reference.

betajet
User Rank
CEO
Hooray for Heathkit!
betajet   10/21/2013 7:49:59 PM
NO RATINGS
I remember Heathkit schematics as being particularly well-drawn.  I think a lot of the quality of the older drawings was that mechanical drawing was at that time a required engineering skill and something people did with great pride.  A sloppy drawing indicated sloppy engineering.  In Jules Verne's The Begum's Fortune (1879), the hero infiltrates into the enemy's Metropolis-like factory through outstanding mechanical drawing ability.

One of my pet peeves is the terrible automatically-generated logic diagrams one gets from logic synthesizers.  IMO they're practically useless for anything but the simplest designs -- I'd much rather have textual equations.

MeasurementBlues
User Rank
Blogger
Let to right
MeasurementBlues   10/21/2013 9:23:34 PM
NO RATINGS
Schematics should flow left to right except for feedback loops.

MeasurementBlues
User Rank
Blogger
Bridge circuits
MeasurementBlues   10/21/2013 9:28:35 PM
NO RATINGS
Do you draw bridge circuits in a diamond shape or a rectangular shape/ The first time I saw a rectifier circuit drawn in rectangular style, it threw me for a minute or two.



 

or

 



David Ashton
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Bridge circuits
David Ashton   10/21/2013 10:41:03 PM
NO RATINGS
Diamond's much nicer.  It LOOKS like the part.

rick merritt
User Rank
Author
Re: Schematics
rick merritt   10/21/2013 11:11:44 PM
NO RATINGS
Our former analog editor Stephan Ohr educated me about the value of good schematics.

Page 1 / 4   >   >>
Radio
NEXT UPCOMING BROADCAST
EE Times Senior Technical Editor Martin Rowe will interview EMC engineer Kenneth Wyatt.
Top Comments of the Week
Like Us on Facebook

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed
Flash Poll