REGISTER | LOGIN
Breaking News
Blog

Patented Software, the Supreme Court & Abstract Idea Hearings

NO RATINGS
View Comments: Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
betajet
User Rank
Author
Re: Software patents are silly after all...
betajet   7/19/2014 4:08:52 PM
NO RATINGS
Navelpluis wrote: What I really really don't understand is why copyright is protected for such a long time.

The answer is pretty simple: if Mickey Mouse and Superman become public domain, anyone can use them as characters as shown in this brilliant Tom the Dancing Bug cartoon by Ruben Bolling.  He also created this wonderful cartoon, in which the League of Public Domain Properties tries to rescue a victim from the chains of death-plus-70-years (for now) copyright.

Navelpluis
User Rank
Author
Software patents are silly after all...
Navelpluis   7/19/2014 3:09:24 PM
NO RATINGS
Please do not forget that software patents will mainly kill the smaller companies. They simply don't have the power to protect their IP. Apart from this you have to consider that software pantents certainly will delay engineering processing and innovation. Hardware patents is another ballgame. You need to protect your physical IP, otherwise others will copy it. The same problem arises about the protection, but with hardware -at least- you can find people that understand your issues and are able to help you to protect your IP. (no cure no pay, etc)

What I really really don't understand is why copyright is protected for such a long time. Even after 70 years the family of the former owner can claim. Compare this with the 12 years of hardware patent duration. I think that it would be a good idea if all go back to at most 10 years. And no software patents because of the sillyness of it, seen a few, I laughed my pants off... what a b*llsh*t....

SteveRubin
User Rank
Author
What is "abstract"?
SteveRubin   7/18/2014 6:16:44 PM
NO RATINGS
Susan, I think your concern identifies the problem.  I don't think anyone, even the Supreme Court, knows what "abstract" means. Further, even if we did know what "abstract" is, at what level of abstraction should we be looking?  

przem
User Rank
Author
Re: Abstract is too abstract
przem   7/18/2014 4:59:21 PM
NO RATINGS
There's this old parlor game where you add 'in bed' to advice from fortune cookies ("look for new opportunities"), and everyone has a good laugh. I found it only briefly amusing. It seems to me that the SCOTUS is essentially saying that just adding a similar qualifier  ("on a computer") is not sufficient to make an idea novel or patentable.

betajet
User Rank
Author
Re: Abstract is too abstract
betajet   7/11/2014 3:48:45 PM
NO RATINGS
I don't think anyone understands what SCOTUS (Supreme Court of the United States) means by "abstract", including SCOTUS.  From what I can tell, it's like Justice Potter Stewart's famous quote about obscenity: "I know it when I see it" [Wikipedia].

It remains to be seen if lower courts start tossing out software patents on the basis of "too abstract".  My guess is that more cases will be appealed to SCOTUS and the "software patent tax" on technology products will keep rising.  When SCOTUS gets tired of hearing yet another abstract patent case, then they'll come up with a reasonable test.

Susan Rambo
User Rank
Author
Abstract is too abstract
Susan Rambo   7/11/2014 2:01:32 PM
NO RATINGS
I still don't get the abstract concept in patents. Does anyone else have trouble with this?

More Blogs
Founder of Tesla and SpaceX says it's imperative that society regulate the advance of artificial intelligence.
Changes in antennas, displays, in-vehicle networks and new digital radio standards have made car radios much more versatile, while bringing new challenges to car radio vendors.
There’s no question that AI is redefining processes across a whole spectrum of businesses. There is, however, a question of what that means for the overall economy. Canada is now investing in AI research with the expectation that it will benefit the country in general.
Flexible hybrid electronics can deliver much of what is promised for the future world of the Internet of Things.
Using the simulation platforms, an automotive design engineer can perform all major tests that can be done on a physical prototype and any test that is difficult to perform or requires specialized testing equipment.
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed