Design Article
Inexpensive analog isolation using a digital isolator
Michael Score
12/5/2012 8:46 AM EST
Isolation is needed now more than ever with applications like LED lighting, brushless motors, power monitoring, and many others that are a combination of direct offline power electronics with isolated control electronics. These applications typically use a very inexpensive analog voltage control for speed or intensity adjustments, whether through a potentiometer or with an analog interface like 0 to 10V.
An isolated operational amplifier (op amp) is too expensive for most of these high-volume applications. Digital isolation is more cost-effective, but typically requires an analog-to-digital converter (ADC) and multiple digital isolators. This article shows a cost-optimized solution for moving analog across the isolation barrier.
A digital isolator takes a digital input and isolates it, but cannot pass an analog signal. The output is either a 1 or a 0. The simplified digital isolator is just a logic level shifter that adds isolation. Typically a digital isolator is used in an application like this to first convert the analog signal to digital, and then send the digital signal using these isolators.
This method adds cost in the ADC and requires multiple digital isolators for the clock, data, chip select, and any other I/O required to control the ADC, which also adds cost. A single digital isolator can be used, if we can convert the analog data to logic level through a pulse-width-modulated (PWM) signal. The PWM represents a linear voltage by the percentage of time the waveform is in on versus off mode. Duty cycle is the percentage of on time to a given period of time.
The PWM is a cross between analog and digital because you are not sending true digital data like a typical parallel or serial interface, but the signal is either high or low with nothing in between. The PWM deals with timing instead of voltage so any common-mode voltage shift across the isolation barrier does not affect the signal. The PWM signal will be very robust to noise since it is either a 0 or a 1 instead of a small analog voltage.
A class-D amplifier is a very inexpensive way to convert analog to PWM. A class-D amplifier block diagram is shown in Figure 1. The class-D amplifier takes an analog voltage and outputs a pulse-width modulated signal. We choose the TPA2006D1 for this design because it is very inexpensive, small, and has very few external components. The class-D amplifier outputs 50 percent duty cycle for IN+ = IN–. The duty cycle is less than 50 percent for IN+ < IN– down to zero percent and greater than 50 percent for IN+ > IN– up to 100 percent.

Figure 1: Class-D amplifier block diagram.
Next: Figure 2 PWM signal


gabex
12/6/2012 5:00 AM EST
Kudos, man. The idea of encoding the precious amplitude information in time-domain is perfect. You get rid of the non-linearity of an usual isolation barrier, and can keep the time-resolution based inaccuracies of the PWM translation relatively low using high PWM freq. I wish all EEs would be capable of coming up with such original ideas - the world would be a better place. Article of the month.
Sign in to Reply
dates
12/6/2012 4:28 PM EST
Also look at AMC1200, which has used this technique and has an input range of +/-250mV
http://www.ti.com/product/amc1200
Sign in to Reply
Marvin.Malm
12/10/2012 5:24 PM EST
This is not a low cost solution when you need really good isolation. The power supplies will offset any savings over a transformer. I have designed many MODEMS and mostly use good transformers. They provide isolation from near misses with lightning strikes and maintain excellent common mode rejection. Add a power supply and common mode rejection goes away.
Marvin F. Malm PE
Sign in to Reply
MikeScoreTI
1/7/2013 4:00 PM EST
Marvin,
I agree that a good transformer is best solution for your case where you don’t need an isolated supply for any other reason. Many systems already have an isolated and non-isolated supply. In this case, adding a class-D amplifier (TPA2006D1 with a $0.35 1ku web price) and an extra digital isolator channel makes for cheap way of adding analog isolation.
Sign in to Reply
waynecfite
1/17/2013 8:33 AM EST
Marvin,
This solution also provides a good way to pass DC voltages through the isolated barrier.
Common mode rejection is also covered, since the signal is digitized. Common mode noise between the two system grounds will have little impact on the timing information used to recover the signal.
Sign in to Reply