Design Article
Shrinking radios for millimeter-scale computers
David Blaauw, David Wentzloff, Dennis Sylvester, University of Michigan
3/14/2011 9:28 PM EDT
Nearly invisible millimeter-scale systems could enable ubiquitous computing, and are the next class of computers predicted by Bell’s Law to fuel growth in the semiconductor industry. Bell’s Law is a corollary to Moore's Law, which predicts a new class of smaller, cheaper computers about every decade. With each new class, the volume shrinks by two orders of magnitude and the number of systems per person increases. The law has held from 1960s' mainframes through the '80s' personal computers, the '90s' notebooks and the new millennium's smart phones.
Tiny, battery-operated wireless systems are the future of monitoring our bodies, environment, and buildings. There are several challenges to realizing complete mm-scale systems, in particular in the design of the wireless interface. Typical wireless radios have high peak power consumption, which cannot be sustained by micro batteries with peak currents of 10μA. They also use large off-chip antennas and precision crystal frequency references, which do not scale to volumes below 1mm3, or integrate with CMOS processes. In order to realize true mm-scale wireless systems, we are developing fully-integrated 1mm3 radios and antennas with strict limits on peak-power and energy/bit, and that eliminate the need for an external crystal reference.
Intraocular Pressure Monitor
Glaucoma is the leading cause of blindness in the world, affecting 67 million people worldwide. It is caused by the elevated intraocular pressure (IOP) which damages the optic nerve. A mm3 sensor node inside the anterior chamber can be very helpful in monitoring the IOP. We have recently demonstrated a sensor node that is able to wake up upon reception of an external wakeup signal (downlink) and transmit recorded data back to the external unit (uplink). An asymmetric near-field (inductively coupled) wireless link is a suitable choice due to highly constrained area and power budget on the implant side.

Figure 1: Die micrograph of the wireless radio for the intraocular pressure (IOP) sensor.
The uplink consists of an oscillator with dual resonator tank. The dual-resonator architecture enables the two FSK tones to be far apart and thus relaxes the constraints on the phase noise of the oscillator. Obviously, bigger coils with multiple turns are desired to achieve higher transmission range. In order to provide enough negative resistance to oscillate a tank with these inductors and achieve cm-range transmit distance, tens of milliamps of power should be supplied from the power source. Since the thin film battery peak current is only tens of micro amps, the transmitter operates off a total of 1.6nF of decoupling capacitors spread all across the chip. Upon transmission of every bit, the oscillator is turned off to give the capacitors enough time to recharge. This way, we overcame the peak current issue by trading off bitrate, which is not limiting in our system.
On the downlink side, the same dual-resonator tank is used to couple to the external unit. The voltages across the two tanks are rectified and compared against each other using a comparator with digitally-tunable offset. This approach eliminates the need for power-hungry voltage references and provides immunity to common-mode input fluctuations.
Antenna-Referenced Fully-Integrated Radios
In order to eliminate the bulky off-chip component and reduce the size of the wireless system, we recently demonstrated a fully integrated radio based on an antenna-referenced concept. The main idea is using an on-chip patch antenna as both the radiator and a frequency reference. The patch antenna operates in the 60GHz band, with dimensions of 1.2mm x 1.6mm. The frequency reference is the resonance frequency of the patch antenna, which is mainly determined by the width, length and height of the patch. The accuracy is robust over process variation because the metal variations in scaled CMOS is relatively small compared to the size of the antenna. Based on the measurement results of twenty replica antennas, a standard deviation of 1100 ppm on antenna resonance frequency variation is obtained. This tolerance is adequate for FCC compliance, and for non-coherent energy detection communication commonly used in tiny, battery-operated wireless sensor systems.

Figure 2: Die micrograph of the fully integrated 60GHz patch antenna with antenna-referenced frequency-locked loop
With the antenna reference, we built a frequency-locked loop to track the resonance of the patch antenna. By monitoring the difference in standing wave voltage magnitude observed at two tap points along the edge of the patch antenna that are equally spaced away from the length center, we can trace out a monotonic curve that crosses zero only at the resonant frequency of the antenna. By using this as the frequency detector, we operate the antenna in a closed-loop controller to tune an oscillator to the appropriate frequency.
To further reduce the size of a complete mm3 system including processor, memory, and sensors, we implemented the patch antenna with a ground plane in metal 4. This provides area for other circuitry and routing beneath the antenna that is shielded by the ground plane. The baseband building blocks of the frequency-locked loop are all implemented beneath the antenna using this area, and an additional unused area of 1mm2 is available beneath the antenna for other circuits.
Acknowledgements:
The IOP sensor was designed by graduate students Gregory Chen, David Fick, Hassan Ghaed, Razi-ul Haque, Daeyeon Kim, Gyouho Kim, Yejoong Kim, Mingoo Seok, and post-doctoral researcher Michael Wieckowski. The antenna-referenced frequency-locked loop was designed by graduate student Kuo-Ken Huang.


janine.love
3/14/2011 9:43 PM EDT
I read about this work on implantable glaucoma pressure monitors from the team at the University of Michigan last month. I asked them for a write up, and here it is. Please post any questions or comments here.
Sign in to Reply
Nasir
3/16/2011 3:18 AM EDT
This is great work for the new generation of Mankind.
The ideas of elimination of Voltage reference and
reference crystal will bring big revolution.
Well done.
Nasir Ahmed
Chief Engineer
Silicon International
Karachi Pakistan
nasir2ahmed@yahoo.com
Sign in to Reply
Qzz
3/16/2011 10:57 AM EDT
Are any issues with signal aborbed in body tissue at 60Ghz? In previous life I used the antenna as the resonant circuit to increase the radiation efficiency.
Sign in to Reply
Luis Sanchez
3/17/2011 4:28 PM EDT
Wow! quite interesting that strategy of using several capacitors to get the extra current required for achieving a proper range in the uplink specially considering the size of the system.
Though, 60 GHz doesn't appear to be compatible with the current PAN radio technologies like Bluetooth or upcoming NFC.
Will this start the search for a new standard?
No mention of the achieved bit rate? is it that slow?!
Sign in to Reply
mhaghaed
3/18/2011 11:41 AM EDT
The achieved bitrate is ~20kbps. Note that if we replace the battery is replaced with a power supply, we can get 10Mbps. However, we need to re-charge the local storage caps before transmitting each bit
Sign in to Reply
new2coding
3/17/2011 5:34 PM EDT
At 60 GHz this will be able to be beem formed with mimo extending range by orders of magnitude.
since each radio in a mesh will be spacially located then these mimo equiped mini radios can be optimized for a given mesh layout for reliable power levels for R&T but have the minimum possible power used for transmission and the best SNR for recieve.
Sign in to Reply
new2coding
3/17/2011 5:34 PM EDT
Trick will be getting the MIMO to fit on the chip I suppose.
Sign in to Reply
new2coding
3/17/2011 5:44 PM EDT
How is the clock mantained when the antenna-tank oscillator is turned off?
does it not keep a lock?
does it have to re-aquire the freq lock?
Sign in to Reply
new2coding
3/17/2011 5:47 PM EDT
How is the dual tank implemented in the example when using the patch antenna as the L in a LC tank?
do you use the FLL resonance rectified amplitude to compare with the modulated signal to determine frequency or phase shift?
Sign in to Reply
mhaghaed
3/18/2011 11:44 AM EDT
The dual-resonator tank is implemented using spiral integrated inductors and MIM caps. Note the patch antenna is a separate module.
Sign in to Reply
new2coding
3/18/2011 12:13 PM EDT
HAVE YOU THOUGHT ABOUT OR LOOKED INTO THE BATTERY ic OPTIONS?
Cymbet is one company that comes to mind.
I can't remember if they are the IC type or a just a thin membrane type.
If this could be integrated under the shield or on the bottom of the package below the die.
Sign in to Reply
david.may
3/19/2011 12:16 PM EDT
oc i dont see any reference to you considering so called "fractal patch antenna" to also allow MIMO in the reduced space
https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.urel.feec.vutbr.cz%2Fra2008%2Farchive%2Fra2005%2Fpapers%2F215.pdf
and also make a separate wireless power circuit as well as these cap's etc
fractal's are good for lots of things it seems, especially as you shrink down to save costs and open new markets :D
https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.jpier.org%2FPIERL%2Fpierl06%2F08.08121309.pdf
getting product ready for mass production in a timely manor seem like a larger challenge today
Sign in to Reply
Paul Lovoi Ph.,D.
3/23/2011 5:11 PM EDT
I would like one of the authors to contact me
palovoi@tagent.com
Thanks
Paul Lovoi
Sign in to Reply