Design Article
Vibration energy harvesting for wireless sensor networks: Assessments and perspectives
Sebastien Boisseau and Ghislain Despesse, CEA-Leti
4/12/2012 10:13 AM EDT
Non-linear effects and tuning of frequency to increase VEh frequency response
This physical limit in standard linear behavior is probably the main reason why VEh are not widespread today. Fortunately, solutions to increase VEh frequency bandwidth are currently being investigated.
In fact, two main ways exist in the state of the art to widen VEh frequency bandwidth: use of non-linear effects (passive) and tuning of frequencies (active). We present here, as examples, some solutions currently being studied in our labs.
Non-linear effects are present in all mechanical structures but have only begun to be exploited to increase VEh output. Non-linear effects do not have to be activated by a control circuit – they are passive phenomena. They are added to the VEh structure during manufacturing and appear as soon as springs leave the linear domain (for high amplitude displacements). We have already proven that thanks to non-linear behaviors, VEh output power can be increased by 50 percent compared to standard linear behaviors in some cases (car engines, motors).
Even though non-linear effects have proven attractive to increase VEh output power and reliability, ”tuning of frequencies” is the most promising way to increase VEh frequency bandwidth. Its objective is to change VEh natural frequency by modifying spring stiffness. These changes are controlled by an active circuit aimed at searching optimal parameters to maximize output power. Two main ways are currently under study in our labs on piezoelectric VEh.
The first one consists in using three-layered beams made of two piezoelectric layers and a silicon beam (Figure 7a). Piezo 1 (Figure 7a) is linked to a control circuit that applies a voltage able to modify piezo 1 stiffness and therefore beam resonant frequency. Energy is harvested on piezo 2 (Figure 7a).
The second method is based on electrical load adjustment. When piezoelectric layers have strong coupling coefficients, it is possible to modify layer stiffness (and therefore resonant frequency) by adapting the load (Figure 7b).

This physical limit in standard linear behavior is probably the main reason why VEh are not widespread today. Fortunately, solutions to increase VEh frequency bandwidth are currently being investigated.
In fact, two main ways exist in the state of the art to widen VEh frequency bandwidth: use of non-linear effects (passive) and tuning of frequencies (active). We present here, as examples, some solutions currently being studied in our labs.
Non-linear effects are present in all mechanical structures but have only begun to be exploited to increase VEh output. Non-linear effects do not have to be activated by a control circuit – they are passive phenomena. They are added to the VEh structure during manufacturing and appear as soon as springs leave the linear domain (for high amplitude displacements). We have already proven that thanks to non-linear behaviors, VEh output power can be increased by 50 percent compared to standard linear behaviors in some cases (car engines, motors).
Even though non-linear effects have proven attractive to increase VEh output power and reliability, ”tuning of frequencies” is the most promising way to increase VEh frequency bandwidth. Its objective is to change VEh natural frequency by modifying spring stiffness. These changes are controlled by an active circuit aimed at searching optimal parameters to maximize output power. Two main ways are currently under study in our labs on piezoelectric VEh.
The first one consists in using three-layered beams made of two piezoelectric layers and a silicon beam (Figure 7a). Piezo 1 (Figure 7a) is linked to a control circuit that applies a voltage able to modify piezo 1 stiffness and therefore beam resonant frequency. Energy is harvested on piezo 2 (Figure 7a).
The second method is based on electrical load adjustment. When piezoelectric layers have strong coupling coefficients, it is possible to modify layer stiffness (and therefore resonant frequency) by adapting the load (Figure 7b).

Figure 7: Piezoelectric VEh applying tuning of frequency a) by applying an electric field and b) by changing the load
(Click on image to enlarge)
(Click on image to enlarge)
Thanks to these methods, VEh resonant frequency can be tuned over a range representing up to 20 percent of their main resonant frequency.
Navigate to related information


docdivakar
4/18/2012 11:30 AM EDT
I wish figures were hyperlinked to their larger size versions; figure 2 which is an important one to understand is unreadable; same problems with figure 5, and 7.
I did like the authors' tripartite approach the energy harvesting and utilization problem.
Surely, the approach can be extended to multiple spring mass systems; such an ensemble has the advantage of not needing fine tuning to optimize a system as long as the bounds of the dominant resonant frequencies are known.
MP Divakar
Sign in to Reply
anne-francoise.pele
7/16/2012 11:25 AM EDT
Dear DocDivakar,
You can now click on Figures 2, 5 and 7 to getter a larger and more readable view.
Sign in to Reply
anne-francoise.pele
7/16/2012 11:25 AM EDT
FYI, Stephane Boisseau and Ghislain Despesse at the CEA-Leti (France) also contributed the article, entitled: "Energy harvesting, wireless sensor networks & opportunities for industrial applications".
The link to the article is: http://www.eetimes.com/design/smart-energy-design/4237022/Energy-harvesting--wireless-sensor-networks---opportunities-for-industrial-applications
Sign in to Reply
anne-francoise.pele
7/20/2012 5:18 PM EDT
Click on the link below to check out the collection of the Design Articles, Case Studies, Product How-To articles, Teardowns, etc... related to energy scavenging that have been published on Smart Energy Designline.
Click here: http://www.eetimes.com/design/smart-energy-design/4372778/Energy-harvesting---Design-archive
Check back frequently. The list will be updated as new articles arrive.
Sign in to Reply
docdivakar
10/8/2012 12:32 PM EDT
@anne-francoise.pele; I appreciate the follow up and the links (& the larger versions of figures in the article!).
The need for cost-effective energy harvesting sensor nodes can not be overstated and is critical to deploying sensor networks for infrastructure monitoring.
MP Divakar
Sign in to Reply
Sebastien Boisseau
11/5/2012 3:51 AM EST
FYI : more information on Electrostatic and electret-based energy harvesters : http://www.intechopen.com/books/small-scale-energy-harvesting/electrostatic-conversion-for-vibration-energy-harvesting
Sign in to Reply
iniewski
1/30/2013 4:04 PM EST
Sebastien, great articles...would you be interested in presenting this topic at emerging technologies symposium in Grenoble? www.cmosetr.com, kris.iniewski@gmail.com
Sign in to Reply