Breaking News
News & Analysis

Has Indoor Navigation Lost Its Way?

3/14/2014 09:00 AM EDT
11 comments
NO RATINGS
More Related Links
View Comments: Threaded | Newest First | Oldest First
Tim W
User Rank
Manager
Indoor nav value
Tim W   3/14/2014 11:58:20 AM
NO RATINGS
I wasn't aware that many phones other than my Galaxy Nexus S (Google version) even had a pressure sensor.  It's main value for me has been knee pain prediction; that and watching the pressure drop with the approach of hurricane Lee last year.

As for indoor navigation, I can see the phone integrating the accelerometer output, but that assumes an accurate position fix before going inside a building, with good GPS signals and data connection to a network.  I'm one who keeps the GPS turned off mostly for battery life, but also for personal privacy.  However, I'd pay for an app that could navigate me to items in a grocery store!

D_R_L
User Rank
Rookie
Re: Indoor nav value
D_R_L   3/14/2014 3:43:03 PM
NO RATINGS
The reason indoor navigation has not taken off is due to the fact that the consumer grade MEMS sensors (gyro and accels) that are currently being put into cell phones today are nowhere near good enough (performance wise) for this type of application.  

Consumer grade sensors have too much drift over time to be accurate enough for indoor navigation, hence the statement in the article "often showed the users being outside the mall when they were inside".  The sensor drift causes error in the position and this error adds up very fast vs time. So with consumer grade sensors within 30 seconds you could be 100s - 1000s of meters off from where your phone says you are and where you really are.

I believe in order to make indoor navigation viable with consumer grade sensors another reference will be needed to help correct for the sensor drift.  I know there are various reference schemes that are being investigated such as WiFi and optical to help correct for the drift.  In order to have a succesful indoor navigation experience either the sensors will have to get a LOT better or some reference will also be needed in the sensor fusion to correct for the various sensor drifts.

seaEE
User Rank
CEO
Re: Indoor nav value
seaEE   3/15/2014 5:16:46 PM
NO RATINGS
Is it the sensors that keep drifting, or the mall fountains that keep moving?

AZskibum
User Rank
CEO
Re: Indoor nav value
AZskibum   3/17/2014 9:22:29 AM
NO RATINGS
Regarding indoor vs. outdoor nav and the need, or lack thereof, for pressure sensors -- the one app I have found useful that provides altitude data is one that is used primarily for skiing & snowboarding. It uses GPS to locate the user's x,y and z, and of course is intended only for outdoor use, but does quite a good job of tracking your altitude changes throughout your ski day and easily distinguishes a lift ride up the mountain from a ski run down.

I can't think of many scenarios in which a user would care to know his or her altitude within a building or to know which floor they're on. That is generally something people can keep track of on their own!

 

lucina2014k
User Rank
Rookie
Re: Indoor nav value
lucina2014k   3/16/2014 8:29:30 AM
NO RATINGS
Meanwhile, there is business pressure to component count, cost, and energy consumption and do primary functions well, Ramo indicated. - Flemings Ultimate Garage

Krulwich
User Rank
Rookie
Indoor nav is already taking off....
Krulwich   3/23/2014 5:00:54 AM
NO RATINGS
Indoor nav, including using MEMS sensors, is already taking off. There are over a hundred companies bringing indoor nav to market http://goo.gl/NpA4Vk and virtually all of them are incorporating, or working now to incorporate, use of sensors. This is beacuse radio-based techniques are not precise enough in handling small movements or in handling transitions smoothly. Also, as E911 legislation warms up, barometers for altitude will become increasingly important.

DrQuine
User Rank
CEO
Indoor Navigation Challenge
DrQuine   3/14/2014 5:28:43 PM
NO RATINGS
As I've mentioned elsewhere, the pressure sensor data may be skewed by HVAC (climate control) induced building pressure differentials and by weather induced air pressure changes. At the same time, there is a very real interest by consumers in being able to navigate within large malls and buildings. The building owners also have an interest in people being able to find their way around. A combination of beacons and WiFi transmitters in known locations should enable map programs to determine the geographical location and elevation (floor) of a smartphone. People walk much slower indoors than they drive outdoors so some parts of the problem are simplified. An alternative approach is the use of images taken by the phone to locate the user and then use inertial navigation from there.

jkocurek
User Rank
Rookie
Re: Indoor Navigation Challenge
jkocurek   3/16/2014 7:38:04 PM
NO RATINGS
The comment that consumers don't need it doesn't hold water. The comment that none work very well is more likely the case.

Me, I'd love to have indoor navigation in the big box stores. Make a list if what I want, have it pull location information from the store and then it shows me a map of where the items I want are.


I've wanted to do that since my Telxon days...

mhrackin
User Rank
CEO
Re: Indoor Navigation Challenge
mhrackin   3/17/2014 2:06:01 PM
NO RATINGS
You folks who want indoor location to help you find stuff:  do you think the RETAILERS know where it should be, or or if there is any in stock?  That makes me laugh!  More often then not, I check stock on many large retailers for stock status of an item in nearby stores, and 80% of the time the information is WRONG, either the item shown out of nstock has lots on the shelves, or items shown as in-stock may not even be carried in that particular store!  Happens with Home Depot, Walmart, Sears, etc.   Even the HEADQUARTERS "showplace" Home Depot store I usually patronize suffers from this.  I've been told by store and department managers that part of the problem is they ship stuff to stiores from a centralized regional warehouse in a 53-foot trailer.  Their computers show the items in stock as soon as the trailer is delivered to the parking lot; it may take days or even weeks to get put on the shelves (and then not always where they should be).  Knowing where YOU are is the EASY part!

tb100
User Rank
CEO
WiFi navigation
tb100   3/14/2014 6:15:51 PM
NO RATINGS
I read somewhere that Google uses this technique of doing indoor navigation of buildings and malls by using the known location of all the various WiFi antennas. It is similar to the way that they can do navigation by knowing where the cell stations are.

Assuming there are separate antennas upstairs and downstairs, you wouldn't need a separate altitude (pressure) sensor.

 

I've also heard that mall owners plan to use WFi information along with cell phone ID numbers to figure out people's shopping habits.

_hm
User Rank
CEO
Indoor Navigation -give us solution
_hm   3/15/2014 1:47:50 PM
NO RATINGS
@Peter: Indoor navigation is very desirable solution in many situations. But its solution, both hardware and software algorithms, may be very demanding.

As for Ramo, I would say we expect solution from him and his organization. He should not complain like end user . They make mobile phones, they need market and for that they need to innovate and work hard. Not complain and not act like end user.

 

Most Recent Comments
Susan Rambo
 
y88games
 
Kinnar
 
y88games
 
AZskibum
 
AZskibum
 
AZskibum
 
sixscrews
 
collin0
Most Recent Messages
8/29/2014
5:26:13 AM
Flash Poll
Radio
LATEST ARCHIVED BROADCAST
EE Times editor Junko Yoshida grills two executives --Rick Walker, senior product marketing manager for IoT and home automation for CSR, and Jim Reich, CTO and co-founder at Palatehome.
Like Us on Facebook

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed