datasheets.com EBN.com EDN.com EETimes.com Embedded.com PlanetAnalog.com TechOnline.com  
Events
UBM Tech
UBM Tech

Audio DesignLine Blog

Comment


jcdrisc

3/26/2011 5:17 AM EDT

I always taped my vinyl immediately to play in the car.
A secondary use was ...

More...



ReneCardenas

12/24/2010 5:42 PM EST

The fact that there are pinball machines refurbish at a cost over $3K, tells me ...

More...

Walkman R.I.P., Audi sound

Rich Pell

11/23/2010 12:22 PM EST

A couple of audio-related news items recently caught my eye. First, was the announcement last month that Sony was discontinuing production of its original Walkman cassette player - a story ably covered by Bill Schweber in his nostalgia-tinged look at the Walkman's technological legacy.

My take on the Walkman news? Good riddance as far as I'm concerned. If there's one audio playback/recording medium I cared for even less than vinyl it was cassette tape.

I never did own a Walkman - my mobile cassette listening experiences were limited to in-car players only, on which I used to listen to recorded record albums. The resulting sound quality of course suffered not only from the clicks and pops and distortion of vinyl, but from such added enhancements as noise, high-frequency roll-off and wow and flutter. Still, it served its purpose in this application.

But I did wonder why it took so long for the Walkman to meet its fate. After all it's been 26 years since the portable CD player was introduced and 12 years since MP3 players first made their appearance.

So who's still buying - and listening to - cassette Walkmans? I found some answers in an article on Salon (The Walkman is dead! Long live the Walkman!).

Apparently even now there's still some demand in Europe and developing countries for the original Walkman, and there's even a Walkman Appreciation Society on Facebook. And it turns out, production of the Walkman - while discontinued in Japan - will continue in China. Go figure.

Audi sound
Other recent audio news touched on mobile sound of another sort - the noise (or lack thereof) produced by electric vehicles. There are actually two different aspects to this - one being a safety issue (silent e-cars pose a traffic safety hazard) and the other a branding issue (what should an e-car sound like?).

Car manufacturer Audi, for one, is clearly very serious about addressing this issue and has recently made news with its efforts in searching for the right sound for its future electric vehicles. In looking for just the right innovative sound, the acoustic vehicle designers at Audi have considered everything from the kind of sound associated with traditional combustion engines to that of spaceships in science-fiction movies.

One speculation is that they may choose a sound similar to that of the Audi RSQ in the movie "I, Robot" (video clip (0:43) of the Audi RSQ). Audi's commitment to acoustic branding isn't new, as their own company-produced video (7:38) on the Audi sound (Audi Sound Studio - What is the Audi sound?) clearly shows.

Of course the idea of audio branding with musical advertising jingles has been around forever. But I didn't realize the extent to which some companies are focusing on acoustic branding - and on designing the sound their products make.

I knew this was the case to some extent with automobiles, but was surprised to read about a fully equipped audio testing lab for analyzing the sound of electronic bathroom products. Of course on reflection this sort of testing makes sense as a way to find mechanical problems, but according to the company its purpose is also to "get the sound right." I wonder how many other products are designed with - or could benefit from - such attention paid to acoustic branding?

Comments, questions or suggestions? Email me at rich.pell@verizon.net.





Rick DeMeis

11/23/2010 9:44 PM EST

Re: Silent sound of electric and hybrid vehicles. Why not let the car owner customize the sound the vehicle makes--here are some of the possibilities I mentioned in a previous blog: http://www.examiner.com/automotive-in-boston/hey-you-loser

Sign in to Reply



jwc

11/25/2010 8:39 AM EST

Abandoning the Walkman brand started 20 years ago or more when Sony named its portable disk player "Discman."

That was a mistake. They failed to realized the valuable goodwill that the consistent high quality of those early Walkman products generated. If instead of gradually shelving both the hugely valuable "Walkman" brand and slipping in quality they maintained their quality leadership and named all wearable entertainment products as Walkman variants they would be in better shape now:

Walkman/Cassette - ()
Walkman/Disk - ()
Walkman/MP3 - ()
Walkman/FM - ()
Walkman/MP3/FM - ()
Walkman/MP3/Record - ()
etc.

Abandoning (or neglecting) the brand Walkman was equivalent to Porsche arbitrarily abandoning the brand "Porsche", raising the price, lowering quality standards, and hoping for more sales. (That might happen too.)

Sign in to Reply



BicycleBill

11/28/2010 11:05 PM EST

Sorry, Rich, but you and I will need to have a spirited discussion about the virtues and vices of the Walkman tape cassette player--over some drinks!

Sign in to Reply



rpell2

11/29/2010 3:54 PM EST

I look forward to it anytime, Bill. :)

Actually someone just emailed me that his wife still buys cassette Walkmans to listen to audio books during her daily 5+ mile walks. She sensibly prefers MP3 audio books (on CD), but can't always find books in that format. (There's also the issue of handling convenience that may favor cassette tape over standard-format CD audio books, which need to be changed more frequently.)

So I guess I should qualify my opinion of the Walkman to apply to music listening. (Now I suppose someone's going to come along and claim that analog cassette tape sounds so much better than digital MP3 ...)

Sign in to Reply



ReneCardenas

12/24/2010 5:42 PM EST

The fact that there are pinball machines refurbish at a cost over $3K, tells me there is a nostalgic crowd out there willing to do whatever is takes to restore the experience of old legacy tech. Despite the lag on color, or realistic 3D video effects harnessed with newer game consoles. Likewise, the audio purist and loyal crowd will not be deterred that easily, no matter what is the latest medium.

I would not be surprised to see walkman bodies with latest medium compatibility, to capture that audience and following.

Sign in to Reply



jcdrisc

3/26/2011 5:17 AM EDT

I always taped my vinyl immediately to play in the car.
A secondary use was in my two Walkmans, and for years was happy with that.
I have three excellent Dolby cassette decks I use at home. All the tapes still sound OK and are reliable.
I am an AES member and critical of the MP3 format.
I am not eager to explore it. I have many CDs too.

Sign in to Reply



Please sign in to post comment

Navigate to related information

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)