Digital Home DesignLine Blog

Apple Sample

RF4CE vs IR: the next remote-control "battle"?

Bill Schweber

6/6/2009 12:00 PM EDT

I'm seeing lots of activity in the potential use of RF-based designs to replace the venerable infrared (IR)-based remote control for consumer products. The RF4CE (Radio Frequency for Consumer Electronics) consortium has worked out standards, and recently merged with the Zigbee Alliance to develop all the needed parts of a successful standard: protocols, formats, interfaces, and more. We're also seeing leading IC and other component vendors announcing parts and applications support for RF4CE.

And hopefully, manufacturers will agree on a standard set of commands, to the extent possible, and avoid the Tower of Babel situation we have now, with the different formats and protocol sets used for no clear reason other than to lock you into buying and using "their" remote (yes, you can get so-called universal remotes, but they are a pain to set up and have other issues).

What does this mean for the future of IR? It's not clear. RF4CE offers much more functionality, communication beyond the line-of-sight, and two-way links. No more hunting for that remote control, as you'll be able to signal it from the product it controls to have beep at you and say "here I am." And let's not forget what a potential business opportunity it is for component vendors, as well.

The IR remote has its virtues: it's very cheap, takes little space and power, and fulfills its basic purpose fairly well. It's become truly ubiquitous: you can find it embedded into inexpensive home appliances such as coffee machines, heating pads, fireplaces, curtain controls, and ceiling fans, just to name a few uses. But it has drawbacks, too, with its limited, direct-line range; simplex connectivity; and problems in applications in areas of bright ambient light or sunlight.

It will be interesting to see what traction RF4CE gets over the next few years. Will it push IR out of the way? Will it stumble? Will it be a peaceful IR-to-RF evolution, or a revolution? Will RF4CE brings us closer to the "universal" remote control we keep dreaming about?

Or will peacefully RF4CE coexist with IR in lower-end appliances, and RF4CE in higher-end ones? Let's see what happens.♦.


print

email

rss

Bookmark and Share

Joinpost comment



Comments


LarryM99

7/6/2010 11:56 AM EDT

I have hated RF for years. Last night I spent ten minutes trying to find the RF receiver for the media center that I have in a closet so that I can stick the emitter to it and operate the device. This morning I spent 20 minutes programming the universal remote for the devices in my living room. I would love to have at least an alternative control technology, if not an outright replacement for RF. I understand that change is painful, but at some point it just has to happen.

Larry M.

Sign in to Reply


Please sign in to post comment

Navigate to related information

Product Parts Search

Enter part number or keyword
PartsSearch

EETimes Career Center
FeedbackForm