Weird and Wacky Engineering
Comment
sharps_eng
You may scoff but we really have no idea how a 'swarm' of nerve cells ...
KB3001
Researchers have been thinking about such biological computers for some time ...
Crab computing: building a biological machine
Sylvie Barak
4/19/2012 4:42 PM EDT
Using the crab model
Getting back to the crabs, though, what the Japanese researchers did was to take the whole billiards concept to the next level, substituting balls for swarms of crustaceans which they claimed could “implement logical gates when placed in a geometrically constrained environment.”
Not just any kind of crab fits the experimental bill, however, with researchers opting for soldier crabs who swarm in packs, with the aggressive leaders forming a strong outline for the group, while the crabs in the middle hustle along in a kind of collective crush.
Researchers found that by putting a swarm of soldier crabs into a corridor, they would march along the wall in a similar way to the path of the billiard ball. Even better, because the crabs are biological organisms and respond deterministically to certain external stimuli, they could be easily controlled by the scientists, who experimented by casting shadows over the swarm from above, to simulate crab-eating birds. In the interest of self-preservation, the crabs instinctively moved away from those shadows.
Also, as various groups of soldier crabs bumped into each other, researchers noted that they seemed to merge before continuing on in the direction that was the sum of their respective velocities.

This is cool because it used the natural tendencies of crabs to run together as a group, or split apart from the group, as a kind of logical gate.
Since a logical gate is one of the fundamental parts of an electronic circuit, what the researchers actually managed to prove is that whatever can be done in an electronic circuit is also possible with large numbers of crabs. Which is kind of neat, if you think about it. Not a crabby idea at all.
Of course, it’s not the first instance of biology meeting computing. There’s "ant hill optimization," the mathematical trick to optimize algorithms, but simulating a whole computer out of little creatures really still puts the icing on the crab cake in my personal opinion.
And who knows, maybe it’s a real step towards a future biological-based real, working computer.
Imagine it: a computer whose computational units are based on living matter, or organic molecules. No electricity required, just some food substrate.
Maybe it's a step toward a biological-based computer.
If scientists found a way to actually make that happen, it might even come to embody the old Douglas Adams notion of the the entire earth being a huge computer, designed by an alien race to calculate the answer to life, the universe, and everything.
Although, we already know that the answer to that is 42.
Getting back to the crabs, though, what the Japanese researchers did was to take the whole billiards concept to the next level, substituting balls for swarms of crustaceans which they claimed could “implement logical gates when placed in a geometrically constrained environment.”
Not just any kind of crab fits the experimental bill, however, with researchers opting for soldier crabs who swarm in packs, with the aggressive leaders forming a strong outline for the group, while the crabs in the middle hustle along in a kind of collective crush.
Researchers found that by putting a swarm of soldier crabs into a corridor, they would march along the wall in a similar way to the path of the billiard ball. Even better, because the crabs are biological organisms and respond deterministically to certain external stimuli, they could be easily controlled by the scientists, who experimented by casting shadows over the swarm from above, to simulate crab-eating birds. In the interest of self-preservation, the crabs instinctively moved away from those shadows.
Also, as various groups of soldier crabs bumped into each other, researchers noted that they seemed to merge before continuing on in the direction that was the sum of their respective velocities.

This is cool because it used the natural tendencies of crabs to run together as a group, or split apart from the group, as a kind of logical gate.
Since a logical gate is one of the fundamental parts of an electronic circuit, what the researchers actually managed to prove is that whatever can be done in an electronic circuit is also possible with large numbers of crabs. Which is kind of neat, if you think about it. Not a crabby idea at all.
Of course, it’s not the first instance of biology meeting computing. There’s "ant hill optimization," the mathematical trick to optimize algorithms, but simulating a whole computer out of little creatures really still puts the icing on the crab cake in my personal opinion.
And who knows, maybe it’s a real step towards a future biological-based real, working computer.
Imagine it: a computer whose computational units are based on living matter, or organic molecules. No electricity required, just some food substrate.
Maybe it's a step toward a biological-based computer.
If scientists found a way to actually make that happen, it might even come to embody the old Douglas Adams notion of the the entire earth being a huge computer, designed by an alien race to calculate the answer to life, the universe, and everything.
Although, we already know that the answer to that is 42.
Navigate to related information


iniewski
4/19/2012 6:17 PM EDT
Pretty cool Sylvie...can't wait to get one of those bilogical computers...ideally if it could eat my food waste to generate energy for its own operation that would be fantastic ;-)...Kris
Sign in to Reply
dylan.mcgrath
4/20/2012 1:40 AM EDT
This is seriously mind boggling. I want to know how they got into a room together and decided that their next project should be building a computer based on soldier crabs. seriously? Have all of the other mysteries of science been solved?
Sign in to Reply
prabhakar_deosthali
4/20/2012 7:18 AM EDT
This could be a great new idea but will it be possible to have it in a miniaturized form as small as today's electronic circuits?
Sign in to Reply
KB3001
4/20/2012 10:30 AM EDT
Researchers have been thinking about such biological computers for some time now. Except for niche applications, such computers have serious issues to do with dependability, generalisability, and scalability.
Sign in to Reply
sharps_eng
4/23/2012 2:24 PM EDT
You may scoff but we really have no idea how a 'swarm' of nerve cells communicating in a brain adds up to intelligence, and there is precedent to say that examining macro behaviour can throw light on the micro-opeations within.
So blue sky research into crab swarms, even as seen through a journalist's funfair-distorting lens, is as good a way as any to gather insights into life's mysteries. What's important is good observation, good recording, and good peer publication.
So, examining the behaviour of journalists and their subjects tells us what, exactly?
Sign in to Reply