News & Analysis
Comment
chanj
Working with partners requires quite a bit of resources. Huawei is relatively ...
junko.yoshida
Got it. Thanks. It's true that Samsung settled with Microsoft. HTC has gotten ...
Yoshida in China: Huawei MIA in Windows Phone 8
Junko Yoshida
10/31/2012 11:14 AM EDT
NEW YORK – The reporter in me finds it more interesting to figure out who's missing in action at a big media event like Microsoft’s Windows Phone 8 announcement rather than focusing on the media hogs.
Among the conspicuous no-shows at Microsoft's extravaganza in San Francisco this week were China’s Huawei and the U.S. carrier Sprint Nextel, whose sale to Japan’s Softbank was announced earlier this month.
Where was Huawei, China's leading telecommunications equipment maker and a legitimate contender in the global wireless market? According to reports, one Huawei executive stated in a blog posted to Sina Weibo, China’s equivalent to Twitter, more than 10 days ago, that the company would skip the Windows Phone 8 launch due to a “Sino-U.S. political and economic storm.”
Unfortunately, we can’t verify this since I haven’t been able to find the alleged blog post on Weibo and a Huawei hasn't replied to our calls for comment.
But it is a fact that Huawei’s handset was not among those displayed by Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer during the launch. Microsoft showed Windows Phone 8 handsets by Nokia, Samsung and HTC. There was no mention of Huawei.
Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer announces Windows Phone 8.
If Huawei’s conspicuous absence at Microsoft’s event was indeed triggered by politics, the cause and effect are easy to trace. A congressional committee earlier this month issued a report accusing Huawei and China's other large telecom gear maker, ZTE, of designing communications equipment that allows unauthorized access by the Chinese government, a charge that has stoked national security concerns along with fears of corporate espionage.
Regardless of the report's conclusions, they have little to do with Windows Phone 8 handsets developed by a Chinese company. Do the accusations in the House report extend even to Huawei somehow trying to wire up Windows Phone 8 for the purposes of espionage?
Give me a break.
Let’s look next at Sprint Nextel and Windows Phone 8 in Japan.
Next: Win Phone 8 in Japan
Navigate to related information


SylvieBarak
10/31/2012 2:32 PM EDT
Interesting...
wouldn't it perhaps also be that Microsoft windows 8 is not free for OEMs and is not customizable, while Android is? Since Huawei and ZTE seem to like doing their own thing when it comes to Android, perhaps that was a consideration too?
Or maybe they are just being smart and hedging their bets until they see whether Win 8 sinks or swims...
Sign in to Reply
junko.yoshida
10/31/2012 5:25 PM EDT
Huawei's missing-in-action at Microsoft's event this week may not have much to do with the politics, but rather the company's readiness of the final product.
That said, Jannie Luong, Huawei's spokesperson based in the United States, got back to EE Times and gave us the following official comment -- in regards to comments posted on Weibo by the company's vice president Yu Chengdong:
“Huawei has indeed been unfairly caught up in U.S.-China tensions lately so Mr. Yu’s brief observation is understandable. However, again Huawei Device looks forward to working with Microsoft when it officially launches the Windows Phone. We will provide further information about this shortly.”
Sign in to Reply
tb1
10/31/2012 7:28 PM EDT
"wouldn't it perhaps also be that Microsoft windows 8 is not free for OEMs and is not customizable, while Android is? "
Certainly no customizable, but I thought that most Android phone manufacturers are actually paying a fee to Microsoft for every phone sold to avoid patent lawsuits.
Sign in to Reply
junko.yoshida
11/1/2012 12:54 PM EDT
Paying a fee to Microsoft for every Android phone sold to avoid patent lawsuits? I have not heard of that at all. If true, that would be the first...
If you know this for fact, I would like to know. This is unlikely, though, unless MS has some sort of patents that the company asserted, everyone knows about, and everyone needs to pay for.
Sign in to Reply
Jeanshack
11/1/2012 3:56 PM EDT
"Paying a fee to Microsoft for every Android phone sold to avoid patent lawsuits?"
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/sep/28/samsung-microsoft-android-licensing-dispute
The Guardian is fairly reliable ;-)
Sign in to Reply
junko.yoshida
11/1/2012 6:21 PM EDT
Got it. Thanks. It's true that Samsung settled with Microsoft. HTC has gotten into a similar arrangement wtih Microsoft.
Google is still fighting.
But I think it's inaccurate to make a sweeping statement and assumption that "most Android phone manufacturers are actually paying a fee to Microsoft for every phone sold to avoid patent lawsuits."
Legal fights are still ongoing, and it's not like Microsoft sued every Android phone manufacturer.
Sign in to Reply
chanj
11/2/2012 12:55 PM EDT
Working with partners requires quite a bit of resources. Huawei is relatively new compared to HTC, Nokia and Samsung. It is reasonable for MS to focus on top 5 makers.
Sign in to Reply