Breaking News
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
hottechgirl
User Rank
Rookie
re: UWB outlook certainly isn't positive
hottechgirl   2/27/2009 1:01:56 AM
NO RATINGS
I tend to agree with vtraveller. Wi-Fi and UWB were architected for two very different purposes. Wi-Fi for Wireless LAN (i.e. connecting to the internet), UWB for Wireless PAN (i.e. connecting devices together). Just like Ethernet and USB, Wi-Fi and UWB are very complementary technologies. In any case, more wireless is a good thing IMO...

vtraveller
User Rank
Rookie
re: UWB outlook certainly isn't positive
vtraveller   2/26/2009 12:10:14 PM
NO RATINGS
Well I started developing 802.11 products way back in 1999 and have put them into everything from PCs to mobile phones as well golden reference designs in WiFi. What I can say with some authority is that while 802.11 works well it doesn't work well enough in numerous real-world applications. The 2.4GHz band is crowded and suffers co-existence problems. Particularly with BT/WiFi calling in a single handset. People still can't do a BT voip to WiFi call. Exactly the same problem applies to video streaming, which at higher data rates suffers similar co-existence problems. The issue is derived from not enough capacity over-the-air (particularly in mixed-mode backward compatible setups) and mixed support of QOS services both at the 802.11 and TCP/IP levels. Headline figures have also historically been grossly over rated. Only with 802.11n has throughput criteria been measured in payload data rather than transmission speeds (ignoring NAK, retry and rate-adaptation). I think your claims that 802.11 didn't hype-up data rate are utterly wrong; I lived it and had to fight competitors over inflated claims based on headline data rates. On the 5GHz band (originally from 802.11a) theory. 802.11 can't get traction in this band. It has an awful market price-point for Access Points and is only in the Intel chipset due to it being a Microsoft Certified criterion. 5GHz still isn't viable for a lot of people. WiFi power usage is also pretty darn bad. You certainly can't expect a phone to survive beaconing for very long. Then there's the matter of set up and configuration. As 802.11 is a bridge for 802.3 you typically run it with a TCP/IP stack. Getting peripherals to work with this is cumbersome and unreliable. When my HP printer changes its IP address through DHCP (or I'm not connected at start-up to the network) the HP client software uninstalls my printer driver. No-one had ever considered that the network may appear and disappear periodically when using WiFI. Is 802.11 really that usable for peripherals considering its reliance on high-level IP protocols? All I'm saying is that 802.11 creeks at the edges. UWB, particularly WirelessUSB, fits well in solving a lot of these problems: - Good power / bit - Decent fast data rates; products now achieve 150MB/s of real data throughput (i.e. based on file copy times) - Fits well into mobile devices - Great migration path with wired to wireless USB bridging (products can work with existing USB drivers) I'm glad you're keen to compare with WiFi. It highlights exactly why UWB came along. WiFI has a very clear place and solves a clear set of problems. UWB solves a different set and as such I'm unconvinced there's as much overlap as you suggest.

VK CA
User Rank
Rookie
re: UWB outlook certainly isn't positive
VK CA   2/25/2009 6:30:23 PM
NO RATINGS
Low latency video streaming is important for wireless PC docking station, wireless projector and other wireless video applications. I agree with Colombatto about the UWB advantage and WiFi congestion problems associated with the above video applications. If UWB can deliver stable and inexpensive solution then it have a very good chance against WiFi in PAN applications.



Flash Poll
EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
The Engineering Life - Around the Web
Dwight Bues, Systems Engineer

The Case of the Nonexistent Component
Dwight Bues, Systems Engineer
Post a comment
Every engineer has likely had the unfortunate experience of verifying a part's availability with a vendor, only to have the part ultimately wind up either not getting produced or ...

Engineer's Bookshelf
Caleb Kraft

The Martian: A Delightful Exploration of Math, Mars & Feces
Caleb Kraft
6 comments
To say that Andy Weir's The Martian is an exploration of math, Mars, and feces is a slight simplification. I doubt that the author would have any complaints, though.

Design Contests & Competitions
Caleb Kraft

Join The Balancing Act With April's Caption Contest
Caleb Kraft
58 comments
Sometimes it can feel like you're really performing in the big tent when presenting your hardware. This month's caption contest exemplifies this wonderfully.

Engineering Investigations
Caleb Kraft

Frankenstein's Fix: The Winners Announced!
Caleb Kraft
8 comments
The Frankenstein's Fix contest for the Tektronix Scope has finally officially come to an end. We had an incredibly amusing live chat earlier today to announce the winners. However, we ...

Top Comments of the Week
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)