Breaking News
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
<<   <   Page 2 / 2
nicolas.mokhoff
User Rank
Rookie
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
nicolas.mokhoff   8/11/2011 7:49:17 PM
NO RATINGS
I agree with Duane: few new inventions are truly new. If you believe in anything then you have to believe that the inspiration to create is all around us located in a large cosmic dome of ideas. Channeling those ideas into inventions is what defines inventors. Whether it is the telephone or some music composition--the idea for both came from the same source and is just an extension of the human creative process. There must have been many inventors working on the concept of telephony at the same time around the world. One or two have their name recorded for posterity; how many others could have, no one really knows. It's not what we know from the past that defines us, it's how we shape the future that extends us. But being it is summer, the "The Book of General Ignorance" should be a good read.

Duane Benson
User Rank
Blogger
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
Duane Benson   8/11/2011 4:24:19 PM
NO RATINGS
I've known about the telephone invention controversy for quite some time. There's a similar question about the invention of television, the light bulb, modern steel smelting and a host of other inventions. In some cases, it seems that two individuals in different parts of the world discovered the same thing independently and almost simultaneously. This is likely a reflection of the fact that very few inventions are truly new. Most are the culmination of the works of many, many people. Most of those shoulders that inventors stand on are lost to history. Sometimes one of the "simultaneous inventors" had access to the ideas of the other. In many cases, the person written into history is the one that had the best public relations engine. An interesting but probably unanswerable question would be to see: "how many unknown inventions have been completely lost to history because the particular inventor didn't know how to publicize the idea."

prabhakar_deosthali
User Rank
CEO
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
prabhakar_deosthali   8/11/2011 10:52:35 AM
NO RATINGS
I agree that such late discoveries do not make much sense or impact on the general public other than a moment of entertainment. The people who claimed that they were the inventors of a certain thing have already enjoyed their share of glory and the real inventors may have suffered in silence . But after so many centuries these things cannot be reversed. These famous names now only form the part of those GK quizzes and nothing more.

patrick.mannion
User Rank
Staff
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
patrick.mannion   8/10/2011 11:17:17 PM
NO RATINGS
I have to agree, in the end it doesn't really matter that it was Meucci and not Bell. Heck, it was so long ago.. More interestingly,did you know that chicken tikki marsala comes from Glasgow, not India, and that bagpipes aren't Scottish they're.. och, ye should read the bloomin' book. It's just plain fun weekend reading.

Bob Lacovara
User Rank
Rookie
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
Bob Lacovara   8/10/2011 8:19:38 PM
NO RATINGS
Some students care, at least when you catch them in a pensive moment. But each of these assignments of invention suffers from a common experience: "to the victor belongs the spoils." That is to say, credit goes to the guy who banged the world on the head enough with the invention to make it (and his name) stick. Is this fair? What a silly question. Author Jack Vance opines that the universe is 4 billion years old, and in that time frame absolute equity has not existed for even one hour. I agree. (In any event, my favorite is the Lissajous curve, which seems to have been described first by Nathaniel Bowditch. Oh well.) Still, the book might be worth a look...

Charles.Desassure
User Rank
Manager
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
Charles.Desassure   8/10/2011 2:45:58 PM
NO RATINGS
I think everyone knows about controversy of these inventions. The real question here is? Do you think that this generation of students really cares? Just correct these items in the history textbooks and move on.

Sanjib.A
User Rank
CEO
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
Sanjib.A   8/10/2011 3:42:00 AM
NO RATINGS
Does the book mention about the controversy about the original inventor to radio? Though it is known that Guglielmo Marconi (Italy) was the inventor of wireless but it is argued by many that the oriiginal inventor was Sir Jagadish Chandra Bose (India). :) http://web.mit.edu/varun_ag/www/bose_real_inventor.pdf

Bert22306
User Rank
CEO
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
Bert22306   8/9/2011 10:38:22 PM
NO RATINGS
This controversy has been well known in Italy for a lot longer than I've been alive. Wikipedia has a good summary of the history, which includes Meucci and Bell, but also other early experimenters. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invention_of_the_telephone

old account Frank Eory
User Rank
Rookie
re: Alexander Graham Bell vs Antonio Meucci
old account Frank Eory   8/9/2011 10:14:56 PM
NO RATINGS
Every engineer knows about the controversy between Newton and Leibniz over the invention of calculus, but I had never before heard of this controversy over the invention of the telephone. This sounds like a book I need to add to my summer reading list.

<<   <   Page 2 / 2


EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
Max Maxfield

How to Fly Without Catching the Dreaded Lurgy?
Max Maxfield
21 comments
I am currently not wearing my happy face. In fact, I am a "poorly soldier," as my mother would say when I was a little lad.

EDN Staff

11 Summer Vacation Spots for Engineers
EDN Staff
19 comments
This collection of places from technology history, museums, and modern marvels is a roadmap for an engineering adventure that will take you around the world. Here are just a few spots ...

Glen Chenier

Engineers Solve Analog/Digital Problem, Invent Creative Expletives
Glen Chenier
15 comments
- An analog engineer and a digital engineer join forces, use their respective skills, and pull a few bunnies out of a hat to troubleshoot a system with which they are completely ...

Larry Desjardin

Engineers Should Study Finance: 5 Reasons Why
Larry Desjardin
45 comments
I'm a big proponent of engineers learning financial basics. Why? Because engineers are making decisions all the time, in multiple ways. Having a good financial understanding guides these ...

Flash Poll
Top Comments of the Week
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)