Design Con 2015
Breaking News
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
<<   <   Page 7 / 14   >   >>
Some Guy
User Rank
Manager
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
Some Guy   8/28/2012 10:43:26 PM
NO RATINGS
... by technical committees ... You mean like a panel of Appellate Judges. That's the next stop on the ride. :)

Some Guy
User Rank
Manager
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
Some Guy   8/28/2012 10:41:11 PM
NO RATINGS
So it's the nature of a design patent that a shape can be patented. For 35 years, Honeywell was the only one that could sell a round thermostat.

Some Guy
User Rank
Manager
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
Some Guy   8/28/2012 10:30:38 PM
NO RATINGS
From what to what?

fmotta
User Rank
Freelancer
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
fmotta   8/28/2012 10:21:18 PM
NO RATINGS
I think patent 6,493,002 is invalid due to prior art found in the X-Ray debugging interface as developed on VMS.

fmotta
User Rank
Freelancer
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
fmotta   8/28/2012 10:14:59 PM
NO RATINGS
There would be little surprise amongst many of those who have worked with Apple and its principals if the following conversation took place at Apple some time in the past: "I herein patent the letter 'E' in all its forms and cases. So, therefore all must license 'E' from me." "No, It cannot be 'E' that is too obvious. Let's make it representative of the self centeredness of our corporate values and make it 'I'."

fmotta
User Rank
Freelancer
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
fmotta   8/28/2012 10:08:35 PM
NO RATINGS
@Frank: Most touch based GUIs share similar icons interface. I remember seeing a similar interface the Pico handheld (Made in UK - then acquired by PhoenixBIOS around 1995). Of course so did my Zaurus and my Agenda VR3 & 5.

RTewell
User Rank
Rookie
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
RTewell   8/28/2012 10:06:54 PM
NO RATINGS
Bankruptcy courts (and other finely detailed financial transaction courts) aren't allowed to be jury trials except under VERY specific conditions...and they are exceedingly rare. How is this different? Ask yourself...WHY do bankruptcy courts operate the way they do? This isn't a "RIGHTS" issue...it is an issue of GETTING IT RIGHT. The ramifications and collateral damge from a bad and not well considered decision is too great. We'll see if this stands or if it is heavily modified or retried somehow. I think there is appealable error including jury bias (real or implied) and I am sure that Samsung is looking at ALL the options and I wouldn't be surprised if many others are helping them (like the big G).

fmotta
User Rank
Freelancer
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
fmotta   8/28/2012 9:51:59 PM
NO RATINGS
@hippydog: Jury of peers yes... In other words people who know the subject material. Not lay persons. A simple example might be: It can be hard to teach some people the difference between having a LED and an incandescent light source. These might not be a peer when one is evaluating if a display back lighting method is violating a patent. So, "peers" for technically savvy people are seldom the average living person who has a state issued ID card.

selinz
User Rank
Manager
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
selinz   8/28/2012 9:49:26 PM
NO RATINGS
what can be said that already hasn't? How about the clear "self interest" that Mr. Hogan had. This is evident by him stating that this made his career! Presumably he is being compensated for his interviews, etc. and will probably be able to turn himself into an "expert witness." Perhaps the light bulb was along the lines of "let's see, if we give a really big verdict, I will become famous!" I also agree that the dark room test represents a very poorly thought out experiment that proves nothing but clearly had a very significant effect on the outcome.

old account Frank Eory
User Rank
Rookie
re: Jury foreman in Apple vs. Samsung had 'light bulb moment'
old account Frank Eory   8/28/2012 9:32:10 PM
NO RATINGS
Your opinion and mine, hippydog, seem to be very unpopular, but I agree that this case was a fine example of how well our jury system works. In another article I read, jury foreman Hogan said the jury was very aware that "Apple can't be a monopoly" and they also felt that dubious patents should not be allowed to stand. They threw out the claim that Samsung infringed on Apple's most beloved design patent and they clearly were not impressed with Apple's iPad claims. Some of Apple's claimed damages, the jury felt, were worth zero dollars. Hogan also said he felt that all of the expert witnesses on both sides were paid stooges, and he didn't give a lot of weight to their testimony. Clearly the man is nobody's fool! Many people are arguing for a complete overhaul of the patent system, or for replacing juries in patent cases with some sort of panel of experts, or who knows, how about a panel of lawyers? Sorry, I'd rather that we citizens not give up our rights to a trial by jury or our rights to sit on a jury, weigh evidence and decide a verdict. When it was all said and done, the jury essentially told Apple sorry, you're not getting all that you asked for, some of your patents are not as great as you think they are, and hey Samsung, you willfully copied many elements of the iPhone and you should not have done that. No panel of experts or panel of lawyers could have done nearly as well as this jury of ordinary citizens!

<<   <   Page 7 / 14   >   >>


Top Comments of the Week
Flash Poll
Like Us on Facebook

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
<b><a href=Betajet">

The Circle – The Future's Imperfect in the Present Tense
Betajet
5 comments
The Circle, a satirical, dystopian novel published in 2013 by San Francisco-based writer Dave Eggers, is about a large, very powerful technology company that combines aspects of Google, ...

Max Maxfield

Recommended Reads From the Engineer's Bookshelf
Max Maxfield
27 comments
I'm not sure if I read more than most folks or not, but I do I know that I spend quite a lot of time reading. I hate to be idle, so I always have a book or two somewhere about my person -- ...

Martin Rowe

Make This Engineering Museum a Reality
Martin Rowe
Post a comment
Vincent Valentine is a man on a mission. He wants to make the first house to ever have a telephone into a telephone museum. Without help, it may not happen.

Rich Quinnell

Making the Grade in Industrial Design
Rich Quinnell
16 comments
As every developer knows, there are the paper specifications for a product design, and then there are the real requirements. The paper specs are dry, bland, and rigidly numeric, making ...

Special Video Section
The LT8640 is a 42V, 5A synchronous step-down regulator ...
The LTC2000 high-speed DAC has low noise and excellent ...
How do you protect the load and ensure output continues to ...
General-purpose DACs have applications in instrumentation, ...
Linear Technology demonstrates its latest measurement ...
10:29
Demos from Maxim Integrated at Electronica 2014 show ...
Bosch CEO Stefan Finkbeiner shows off latest combo and ...
STMicroelectronics demoed this simple gesture control ...
Keysight shows you what signals lurk in real-time at 510MHz ...
TE Connectivity's clear-plastic, full-size model car shows ...
Why culture makes Linear Tech a winner.
Recently formed Architects of Modern Power consortium ...
Specially modified Corvette C7 Stingray responds to ex Indy ...
Avago’s ACPL-K30T is the first solid-state driver qualified ...
NXP launches its line of multi-gate, multifunction, ...
Doug Bailey, VP of marketing at Power Integrations, gives a ...
See how to ease software bring-up with DesignWare IP ...
DesignWare IP Prototyping Kits enable fast software ...
This video explores the LT3086, a new member of our LDO+ ...
In today’s modern electronic systems, the need for power ...