Breaking News
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
ratkinson
User Rank
Rookie
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
ratkinson   11/26/2012 9:03:30 PM
NO RATINGS
In response to Brian and George, one can only keep up the good fight and present policy makers with the superior argument. For Bert just because there is an argument to keep a tax incentive does not mean its incorrect or special pleading, just as it would be wrong to say that about spending programs. some are worth continuing and some are not. Its up the policy process to try to figure out which ones are worth it, as is the case with R&D credit. and re BErt's other comment, you are confusing taxes with policies. I think we should cut corp tax rate, but that is not central to the argument for R&D credit, which is that it is a policy that maximizes economic growth more than would be the case if companies just invested on their own accord. Yes, markets do get it wrong. As do companies who are trying to maximize short term equity rather than maximize net present value shareholder value.

Ogemaniac
User Rank
Manager
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
Ogemaniac   11/22/2012 12:23:31 AM
NO RATINGS
You are confusing nominal statuatory rates with actual ones. Our net corporate tax rates are in the low twenties, which puts us right in the middle of the international pack. This, of course, is not a great way to go about things and could use some reform, but it is simply not the case that a typical corporation pays anywhere near 40% in taxes. And yes, targeted tax breaks are subsidies - sometimes justified and sometimes not. Are we better off with simply lower rates, or slighly higher rates plus the R&D credit? The answer is not obvious as there are merits and de-merits to both sides. But it is hard to work through this when one political party just screams "gub'mint bad cut taxes!!!" and refuses to engage in serious discussion.

Bert22306
User Rank
CEO
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
Bert22306   11/21/2012 12:33:25 AM
NO RATINGS
I had to read this twice, to see the logic involved. So, if the government taxes the US operations of corporations to the tune of just about 40 percent, and then it allows the company to retain some more of its profit if it would just spend it on R&D, we need to thank the government for having the foresight to funnel more money into R&D? Because otherwise, the company would never do it on its own? That seems a bit of a stretch. My way of presenting this would instead be, US corporations, for US operations, are taxed at stratospheric levels. However, AT LEAST the government is smart enough to know to give them a break to incentivize R&D. And even so, there are some out there who want to take even that break away, with the idea that really and truly, the government knows best how to spend everyone's money, and the profits of their businesses too.

fundamentals
User Rank
Manager
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
fundamentals   11/20/2012 4:31:29 PM
NO RATINGS
R&D tax credit is indeed a very useful way to incentivize the right kind of activity, but it is much abused by many practitioners. Companies often claim the R&D credit for activities which are not R&D related. In fact, some of these are so ridiculous that it is difficult to classify them as science or enginering of any kind. This is most frequenly done by shifting some SG&A expenses into R&D. It is called creative accounting. Yes the R&D credit should continue, but its common abuse should be stoppped somehow.

danny1024
User Rank
Rookie
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
danny1024   11/20/2012 2:53:06 AM
NO RATINGS
The free market is like gambling in that the combination of skill and luck is frequently rewarded. But like in gambling, the free market can be and is victimized by people, companies and indeed nations that cheat by introducing market distortions that their fellow honest players can only counter by either electing not to play or by cheating themselves.

Ogemaniac
User Rank
Manager
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
Ogemaniac   11/20/2012 12:17:00 AM
NO RATINGS
Well-written article. Yes, the "free market" will under-supply R&D due to positive spill-over externalities. The R&D credit is likely one of the best ways of correcting this very clear and simple market failures. It really is sad how many libertopian-types refuse to admit that "free market" theory is based on a bunch of ridiculous assumptions that are not even remotely valid in the real world, and that the government can and should correct these deviations when practical.

Bert22306
User Rank
CEO
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
Bert22306   11/19/2012 9:52:12 PM
NO RATINGS
Yes, I too thought that the original Rashkin article was strinkingly short-sighted and shallow. Even the point about "for each tax dollar saved, only 1 dollar is spent in R&D" doesn't make a lot of sense. Even if only one dollar extra is spent in R&D, the multiplier is expected DOWNSTREAM, from the products, jobs, etc., that the R&D investment creates. Success of the tax break should not be measured by how much more R&D spending the company does, over and above the tax break. The question is simply, does the tax break create more R&D programs? If the answer is yes, and even Rashkin says the answer is yes, then that's enough. We are facing crippling national debt because of reckless new spending that both the previous administration and this one have created. I know there are those who keep harping on "unpaid wars." That's part of it, but a much greater spike in public spending was caused by the failed government-backed subprime mortgages. Which burst the housing bubble. A housing bubble created by foolish government programs. That's what the original TARP program addressed, and that over-trillion-dollar deficit spending became the "new normal" since 2009. Now the fashion has been to look at taxing more and more, and becoming as creative as possible to "explain" why any previous tax break should be on the chopping block.

Brian Fuller2
User Rank
Rookie
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
Brian Fuller2   11/19/2012 9:02:22 PM
NO RATINGS
A great argument, Robert, but I fear one that faces an uphill battle. In other words I'm less optimistic than George that it will be extended. The tech industry just doesn't seem to have the same lobbying clout as an Idaho potato farmer.

george.leopold
User Rank
Rookie
re: Counterpoint: R&D tax credit spurs innovation
george.leopold   11/19/2012 6:43:39 PM
NO RATINGS
The lame duck session of Congress appears to be consumed with negotiating and the usual posturing over budget "sequestration," aka, "The Fiscal Cliff". The guess here is that perhaps in the course of tinkering with the tax code, lawmakers decide to extend the R&D tax credit for a couple of years to address market "uncertainty" issues.



Most Recent Comments
fragro
 
Sheetal.Pandey
 
prabhakar_deosthali
 
Violoncelles
 
prabhakar_deosthali
 
Violoncelles
 
prabhakar_deosthali
 
wilber_xbox
 
WW Thinker
EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
Max Maxfield

Feast Your Orbs on My Jiggly Exercise Machine
Max Maxfield
45 comments
Last weekend, I was chatting with my mother on the phone. She's all excited that I'm coming over to visit for a week in November. "I'll be seeing you in only seven weeks," she trilled ...

Glen Chenier

Missing Datasheet Details Can Cause Problems
Glen Chenier
3 comments
It is often said that "the devil is in the details." All too often those details are hidden deep within a datasheet, where you can easily overlook them. When a datasheet reference circuit ...

David Blaza

RadioShack: The End Is Nigh!
David Blaza
120 comments
I'm feeling a little nostalgic today as I read about what looks like the imminent demise of RadioShack, at least as we currently know it. An old ubiquitous cartoon image popped into my ...

Larry Desjardin

Engineers Should Study Finance: 5 Reasons Why
Larry Desjardin
46 comments
I'm a big proponent of engineers learning financial basics. Why? Because engineers are making decisions all the time, in multiple ways. Having a good financial understanding guides these ...

Flash Poll
Top Comments of the Week
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)