Embedded Systems Conference
Breaking News
Comments
Doug_S
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
Doug_S   1/18/2013 6:34:53 PM
NO RATINGS
How is this patentable? It is just an idea, and I thought ideas could not be patented. Not to mention the "prior art" from millions of kids who for decades have been pulling/cutting the crusts off their sandwich and pressing together all around the edge with their thumbs. Great example of how broken our patent system is.

bnowak0
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
bnowak0   1/18/2013 9:28:02 PM
NO RATINGS
Ideas can very much be patented, and you’re mistaking 'prior art' with ‘non-obviousness’. A great example of how broken your knowledge of the patent system is.

BrianBailey
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
BrianBailey   1/19/2013 6:38:47 PM
NO RATINGS
Lets all be nice now. This was a regular patent so both prior art and obviousness applied.

WKetel
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
WKetel   1/19/2013 1:39:16 AM
NO RATINGS
This may be a "design patent", which I have found is different from a real patent. But here, as always, the magic is in the claims. Peanut butter on both sides is unusual, and probably not "obvious to anyone in the art", and so it can be covered. But other than that, they do look a whole lot like the sandwiches my Canadian friends used to cook over a campfire. I think that they were called "Pudgy Pies." That was long before 1996. So it seems that some uses of the design may be protected by being grandfathered. Of course, we never attempted to keep them for extended periods of time, but rather only till they cooled enough to eat.

BrianBailey
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
BrianBailey   1/19/2013 6:38:01 PM
NO RATINGS
This is a regular patent and not a design patent, so the patent office thought that a) there was no prior are and b) it was non obvious.

Andy_I
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
Andy_I   1/19/2013 5:08:25 PM
NO RATINGS
Peanut butter on both sides is something I had been doing decades ago. I didn't think it was so unusual. It helps keep the jelly from bleeding through the bread, useful for sandwiches made at breakfast time but not eaten until later in the day. Cutting off the crust, well that wasn't something I used to do (for sandwiches I ate) because I liked some crust. But I did trim the crust for others. So here we have a patent that combines two (or more) practices that have been around for ages. Is that what makes it new, the idea of combining things into the same sandwich? Did the patent elaborate on whether it was white or wheat bread? Hmmm.

BrianBailey
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
BrianBailey   1/19/2013 6:37:23 PM
NO RATINGS
No, it did not make that distinction.

Battar
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
Battar   1/20/2013 7:07:44 AM
NO RATINGS
The question of non-obviousness is subjective. It is assumed that a patent must be non-obvious to someone "ordinarily skilled in the art", which means people normally employed in the field, not experienced engineers who would come up with the same solution. In the case of sandwiches "ordinarily skilled in the art" would be any hungry 8-year old, so the patent application should have been deemed obvious. The examiner probably restricted his prior art search to previous patents. If the examiner had also turned to back issues of "Good housekeeping", I'm pretty sure he would have found something.

Duane Benson
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
Duane Benson   1/21/2013 5:23:01 PM
NO RATINGS
"The examiner probably restricted his prior art search to previous patents" Prior art searches are not supposed to be limited to previous patents. It certainly is possible that the examiner did that, but my understanding is that doing so would not be adequate. Of course, maybe it's so obvious to most people that it's never been written down and the patent examiner just happened to have been raised on cheese sandwiches instead of peanut butter and jelly.

dstauffer193
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
dstauffer193   1/21/2013 7:16:24 AM
NO RATINGS
We have not seen enough of the patent to even know what is patented. Everything in a patent leading up to the claims is just fluff. Until you read the claims (and only the independent ones really matter) you realy cannot tell what the patent actually protects. In the future it would be helpfull to our understanding if the patent number would be included in the article. That way we could easily read the whole patent for educational value.

Battar
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
Battar   1/21/2013 2:29:20 PM
NO RATINGS
Thats US patent 6004596, and the legalistic language used to describe a sandwich is hilarious. (Perimiter coplaner to surface... edible filling juxtaposed...). The claim says, make a sandwich, remove the crust, crimp the edge so the PB doesn't squeeze out. The USPTO shouldn't grant patents for such rubbish.

BrianBailey
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
BrianBailey   1/21/2013 4:04:30 PM
NO RATINGS
Thanks @Battar for supplying the number - I usually do, but failed to on this one. My mistake.

bnowak0
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
bnowak0   1/21/2013 6:36:04 PM
NO RATINGS
Old Timer, as your name suggests you might be unfamiliar with this whole 'internet thing'. See, we have this tool called google. Your generation might call it a voodoo magic machine, mine calls it a search engine. Just plug in any one of the sentences that Brian supplied you with from the abstract into this voodoo machine, and presto, you have the patent staring you right in the face.

Bellhop
User Rank
Author
re: What were they thinking: A crazy patent makes money
Bellhop   1/24/2013 9:16:38 PM
NO RATINGS
The "sandwich" in question is actually on the market and, as far as I know, no one is making a knockoff. http://www.smuckers.com/products/group.aspx?groupId=3



Radio
LATEST ARCHIVED BROADCAST
Overview: Battle-hardened veterans of the electronics industry have heard of the “connected car” so often that they assume it’s a done deal. But do we really know what it takes to get a car connected and what its future entails? Join EE Times editor Junko Yoshida as she moderates a panel of movers and shakers in the connected car business. Executives from Cisco, Siemens and NXP will share ideas, plans and hopes for connected cars and their future. After the first 30 minutes of the radio show, our listeners will have the opportunity to ask questions via live online chat.
Flash Poll
Like Us on Facebook

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
Special Video Section
LED lighting is an important feature in today’s and future ...
Active balancing of series connected battery stacks exists ...
After a four-year absence, Infineon returns to Mobile World ...
A laptop’s 65-watt adapter can be made 6 times smaller and ...
An industry network should have device and data security at ...
The LTC2975 is a four-channel PMBus Power System Manager ...
In this video, a new high speed CMOS output comparator ...
The LT8640 is a 42V, 5A synchronous step-down regulator ...
The LTC2000 high-speed DAC has low noise and excellent ...
How do you protect the load and ensure output continues to ...
General-purpose DACs have applications in instrumentation, ...
Linear Technology demonstrates its latest measurement ...
10:29
Demos from Maxim Integrated at Electronica 2014 show ...
Bosch CEO Stefan Finkbeiner shows off latest combo and ...
STMicroelectronics demoed this simple gesture control ...
Keysight shows you what signals lurk in real-time at 510MHz ...
TE Connectivity's clear-plastic, full-size model car shows ...
Why culture makes Linear Tech a winner.
Recently formed Architects of Modern Power consortium ...
Specially modified Corvette C7 Stingray responds to ex Indy ...