Breaking News
Comments
krisi
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
krisi   3/12/2013 6:40:50 PM
NO RATINGS
1.7Billion!?...how is Marvel stock reacting to this?

SiliconAsia
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
SiliconAsia   3/12/2013 8:12:27 PM
NO RATINGS
Mrvl stock went down to around $7 when this was annoucened from $8.5 in Dec 2012. Now stock price recovered and over performing. It's hovering around $10.5. That's 50% gain since the annoucement! What's going on? No one believes this will impact Mrvl financials?

anon7643463
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
anon7643463   3/12/2013 9:22:43 PM
NO RATINGS
What's going on is market valuation is not always connected to fundamentals.

asic_pal
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
asic_pal   3/13/2013 9:54:04 PM
NO RATINGS
Yeah, I have immediately checked Marvel stock when I last saw the news, there was no reaction in the stock market! I think common investors may not even knew about this case or don't care about it. I think the only law suits people care about is from Apple :)

mcgrathdylan
User Rank
Blogger
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
mcgrathdylan   3/12/2013 6:42:14 PM
NO RATINGS
For the record, it's $1.17 billion. Not sure about the stock. I'll check it out.

Comfortable
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Comfortable   3/12/2013 7:28:57 PM
NO RATINGS
If more people paid attention to how the legal system works in America, I think there would be mass anarchy. Apple sues down the street from Cupertino and guess what? They get a $1B verdict from the local jury to punish the mean out-of-towners for stealing. Carnegie Mellon sues five miles down the road in Pittsburg and guess what? They get a $1B local jury to punish another group of mean out-of-towners for stealing. Pick your venue and "buy" your verdict. Despite what everyone learned in school, the legal system in America is not about blind ladies holding scales, but punishing the entity the jury doesn't like and for whatever reason. Legal bullies if you will. Should it be a surprise that Samsung last month announced a new $1B Innovation Center in the heart of Silicon Valley? Gotta make some local friends to keep those golden scales balanced.

Consultofactus
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Consultofactus   3/13/2013 1:04:21 PM
NO RATINGS
"If more people paid attention to how the legal system works in America" Well I pay attention so I know that our system of juris prudence has a Federal Circuit Court ("Court of Appeals") precisely to review judgments such as this one. "Mass anarchy" might have to wait until the entire legal process has been given the opportunity to work....

Comfortable
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Comfortable   3/13/2013 7:53:48 PM
NO RATINGS
There is a reason that lawyers "practice" law rather than help uphold it. With all due respect, there is nothing in the legal system that is finite or right at any level up to and including the Supreme Court. The process is to first identify which party is the "bad guy", then go find something to use to hang him. With nearly 250 years of case law and millions of patents, there is always something in the records to argue a case one way or the other. If you don't believe this, ask your attorney why you need to wear a nice coat and tie to court.

DrQuine
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
DrQuine   3/13/2013 12:39:28 AM
NO RATINGS
In an era in which the headline making patent cases involve subtle distinctions between products, it is interesting to see a pure technology case. This may result in Carnegie Mellon funds to further improve their well regarded computer science capabilities.

Neo10
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Neo10   3/13/2013 4:22:34 AM
NO RATINGS
If Marvel lost the ruling and the damage is a nine figure number then it is either some joke or really serious infringement, which I doubt. Didn't know Carnegie was so cash strapped!

eewiz
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
eewiz   3/13/2013 10:04:25 AM
NO RATINGS
1.2B for 2 patents is madness. I suspect the Jury might consist of total idiots who have no background in tech. The starting point in such calculations should be the incremental profits that Marvel, made using this particular algo vs a previously used algo. Which by all chances will be less than a few millions. Oh wait.. its not abt damages here. Its abt pittsburg jury supporting local university and education.

nosubject
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
nosubject   3/14/2013 9:19:25 PM
NO RATINGS
"I suspect the Jury might consist of total idiots". The juries are required to be idiot. They have to be regular people without tech knowledge to cause biases. That is the requirement of the US law system. We can imagine the juries for such patent cases are mostly local old ladies and soccer moms. The keywords are "They should not have any STEM background."

resistion
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
resistion   3/13/2013 11:45:31 AM
NO RATINGS
What a ridiculous valuation indeed. I think there would be an appeal or reneg.

Daniel Payne
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Daniel Payne   3/13/2013 3:17:00 PM
NO RATINGS
Remember folks in the Apple lawsuit with Samsung, Apple was awarded damages because of their design patents: A rectangle with rounded corners, a black box, and a Green phone icon. If the jury cannot see prior art in these fundamental areas, then there is no hope for real justice in America with patents.

Battar
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Battar   3/13/2013 3:30:56 PM
NO RATINGS
To prove wilful infrigement, you have to prove that the guilty party actually understood the patent they are infringing. The way some attorneys write patent claims, that can be damn near impossible. I speak from experience. I could also provide examples.

green_is_now
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
green_is_now   3/15/2013 11:50:39 AM
NO RATINGS
tO GET TREBLE DAMAGES

selinz
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
selinz   3/13/2013 5:55:31 PM
NO RATINGS
Is it really necessary to show "willful" infringement? In general, ignorance of the law is not an alibi

Battar
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Battar   3/14/2013 7:54:10 AM
NO RATINGS
Selinz, wilful infringement means learning a competitors invention and deliberatly copying it, other than plain infringement, which means coming up with a similar idea independently later in the day. Both cases are infringement, of course, but for wilful infringement you can claim triple damages.

Comfortable
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
Comfortable   3/13/2013 7:43:50 PM
NO RATINGS
Now that the US Government has protected big industry from the little patent trolls starting on Saturday, how about focusing on protecting the rest of America from the big patent trolls. This is all so ridiculous.

dinky
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
dinky   3/14/2013 7:42:39 PM
NO RATINGS
Why is this new only on EET? tried googling, can't find it anywhere else!

tb1
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
tb1   3/14/2013 7:52:15 PM
NO RATINGS
Lots of knee jerk speeches without much substance here. Has anyone even looked at the patent involved? This isn't some overly broad patent but a very specific patent with detailed mathematical algorithms. Having known someone who claimed that a certain company starting with M partnered with his company then stole all the IP and built it themselves, resulting in many lawsuits he went broke trying to right the wrongs, I wouldn't be so quick to fly off at the handle and make gross generalizations about patents in this case.

eewiz
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
eewiz   3/15/2013 4:47:01 AM
NO RATINGS
I have glanced through the patents. They are about calculating the branch metric in viterbi decoding. Didnt understand the exact advantage of the proposed system. But having worked in similar areas(Wireless PHY design) I can confidently say, there are atleast a 100 other ways of doing the same thing. Not something very unique IMO. Most of the maths you see in that patent is from textbook and not invented by CMU. http://www.google.com/patents?id=SS8JAAAAEBAJ&printsec=abstract&zoom=4#v=onepage&q&f=false http://www.google.com/patents?id=KKQLAAAAEBAJ&printsec=abstract&zoom=4#v=onepage&q&f=false

green_is_now
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
green_is_now   3/15/2013 11:59:05 AM
NO RATINGS
Peoples intelectual property should be respected and paid to use. If willfull stealling is proven. Creaters wronged and that took time to ask for payment and blown off should compensated. The stealing party should be forced to pay extra damages also for court cost above infringment amount. Stealing is thievery, period, and needs too be have enforcment means.

resistion
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
resistion   3/16/2013 1:13:13 PM
NO RATINGS
CMU's name was used in Mean Girls 2 (appropriate?). I wonder how much they were paid for that.

nannasin28
User Rank
Rookie
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
nannasin28   3/19/2013 7:21:56 AM
NO RATINGS
punish another group of mean out-of-towners for stealing. http://www.hqew.net

eewiz
User Rank
CEO
re: Marvell ordered to pay $1.2 billion in patent case
eewiz   3/19/2013 9:16:32 AM
NO RATINGS
SEO-ing your website?



EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
Max Maxfield

Aging Brass: Cow Poop vs. Horse Doo-Doo
Max Maxfield
40 comments
As you may recall, one of the things I want to do with the brass panels I'm using in my Inamorata Prognostication Engine is to make them look really old. Since everything is being mounted ...

EDN Staff

11 Summer Vacation Spots for Engineers
EDN Staff
11 comments
This collection of places from technology history, museums, and modern marvels is a roadmap for an engineering adventure that will take you around the world. Here are just a few spots ...

Glen Chenier

Engineers Solve Analog/Digital Problem, Invent Creative Expletives
Glen Chenier
11 comments
- An analog engineer and a digital engineer join forces, use their respective skills, and pull a few bunnies out of a hat to troubleshoot a system with which they are completely ...

Larry Desjardin

Engineers Should Study Finance: 5 Reasons Why
Larry Desjardin
45 comments
I'm a big proponent of engineers learning financial basics. Why? Because engineers are making decisions all the time, in multiple ways. Having a good financial understanding guides these ...

Flash Poll
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)