Breaking News
Comments
Oldest First | Newest First | Threaded View
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
Sanjib.A
User Rank
CEO
More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
Sanjib.A   10/7/2013 10:52:49 AM
NO RATINGS
The video of the Tesla Model S fire accident is pretty scary. Though it is being justified as being caused by the battery getting damaged by hitting into something and this could be a rare incident, but it is dangerous and could be life threatening. I am sure a detailed investigation would reveal the real reason and something will be done to prevent it, but I guess more research is need in knowing all possible failure modes of of Li-ion battery. Also I learned that the fire from Li-ion batteries is not controlled easily...another area for more research, which I guess is already going on. 

krisi
User Rank
CEO
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
krisi   10/7/2013 1:33:28 PM
NO RATINGS
how is this comparing to a similar accident with a combustion engine car? which one is safer?

Caleb Kraft
User Rank
Blogger
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
Caleb Kraft   10/7/2013 2:26:24 PM
NO RATINGS
Most cars I've been in, something striking the bottom with that much force would have actually entered the cabin. Most cars don't have a quarter inch plate underneath everything.

Caleb Kraft
User Rank
Blogger
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
Caleb Kraft   10/7/2013 2:27:47 PM
NO RATINGS
the combustion potential of that bettery is a fraction of what you would find in a typical gasoline fueled vehicle. Sure, there's a possibility of it catching fire, and that is life threatening, but there's the same risk with your typical gas powere vehicle.

betajet
User Rank
CEO
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
betajet   10/7/2013 2:35:53 PM
NO RATINGS
An electric car battery fire is rare enough to make the front page.  A gasoline car fire is pretty much a daily occurrence in any major USA metro area, so they don't make the front page.


In this case the car told the driver to pull over and exit the car, which he did safely.  Here's a nice write-up comparing what could have happened with a gasoline car.

bmws88
User Rank
Rookie
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
bmws88   10/7/2013 4:04:37 PM
NO RATINGS
Teslas are less than a year old and they've made less than 20,000 of these cars in all (wikipedia). Unless somebody can show me gasoline engine cars catch fire at a higher than 1/20,000 rate in their first year of service, this is a serious issue deserving serious attention.

Bert22306
User Rank
CEO
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
Bert22306   10/7/2013 4:54:40 PM
NO RATINGS
Well, that article isn't very convincing. Nor is it surprising that someone who spends the kind of money to buy a Tesla would not make excuses for it. These are zealots.

It would be nice to have some specifics on what object this car hit. The two articles I've read so far have been too vague to be of any use.

1audio
User Rank
Rookie
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
1audio   10/7/2013 7:46:53 PM
NO RATINGS
The video is scary, as any car fire is. More scary is the report that the fire dept. used water on the Lithium batteries to put it out. Usually that is a very bad idea. What is the right way to douse a lithium fueled fire?

jlindcary
User Rank
Rookie
Re: More research needed on Li-ion battery fire
jlindcary   10/7/2013 7:53:11 PM
NO RATINGS
For goodness sake! Please consider that the technology that you are drawing comparisons between differ greatly in their degree of maturity and their ultimate potential. Gasoline engines are over 100 years old.  The type of electric vehicles that you are drawing unfavorable comparisons against gas engines are, at best, 20 years old and some of the technology is only 5 years old. EVs are only getting started.

 

The MicroMan
User Rank
Rookie
battling fires
The MicroMan   10/7/2013 8:31:39 PM
NO RATINGS
Gasoline, aviation fuel, and other liquid and gaseous fuels have nearly a hundred years of history and billions of examples behind their present day safety.  The last real incident that I remember was the 1970's Ford Pinto needing re-positioning of the gas tank so a rear-end collision wouldn't turn into an inferno. 

While Teslas look to be some of the most amazing cars around, sporty like the (earlier) European sports cars, and highly touted by the Wall Street boys who all want one (as do I), this exotic battery technology just doesn't have the real-life environmental and practical use hours behind it to have the bugs worked out of it in large-scale applications like aircraft and automobiles. 

While an electronic voice warning the passengers to please exit the vehicle as soon as possible may sound comforting to some people, that sounds like a very small band-aid that might not be overly convenient at the time.  I'm certain that I've driven by 20,000 vehicles in the last few months and I don't recall seeing any on fire (this includes EV's and hybrids).  There does seem to be an endless trail of tire treads, 2x4's, furniture, and other debris littered down the highway.  That shouldn't cause a car to burst into flames (or a Concorde). 

If Tesla is going to avoid becoming another Edsel/Corvair/Pinto/Explorer poster boy then it's going to have to completely solve any battery issues, whether or not exotic battery chemistry, behavior, and construction are supposed to be Tesla's core competency.

Page 1 / 2   >   >>


Flash Poll
EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
Engineer's Bookshelf
Caleb Kraft

The Martian: A Delightful Exploration of Math, Mars & Feces
Caleb Kraft
3 comments
To say that Andy Weir's The Martian is an exploration of math, Mars, and feces is a slight simplification. I doubt that the author would have any complaints, though.

The Engineering Life - Around the Web
Caleb Kraft

Surprise TOQ Teardown at EELive!
Caleb Kraft
Post a comment
This year, for EELive! I had a little surprise that I was quite eager to share. Qualcomm had given us a TOQ smart watch in order to award someone a prize. We were given complete freedom to ...

Design Contests & Competitions
Caleb Kraft

Join The Balancing Act With April's Caption Contest
Caleb Kraft
56 comments
Sometimes it can feel like you're really performing in the big tent when presenting your hardware. This month's caption contest exemplifies this wonderfully.

Engineering Investigations
Caleb Kraft

Frankenstein's Fix: The Winners Announced!
Caleb Kraft
8 comments
The Frankenstein's Fix contest for the Tektronix Scope has finally officially come to an end. We had an incredibly amusing live chat earlier today to announce the winners. However, we ...

Top Comments of the Week
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)