Design Con 2015
Breaking News
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
<<   <   Page 3 / 3
MS243
User Rank
Manager
Re: Ease of use, design complexity, cost
MS243   10/24/2013 3:50:40 AM
NO RATINGS
Have recently seen a few designs done using "Free" tools that include complexity like 32bit risc CPU's + FPGA's and matched length DDR traces -- Would have thought this would have only been feasibile with higher end tools a few years ago.   (These are even open source free tools)

Gadgety
User Rank
Freelancer
Ease of use, design complexity, cost
Gadgety   10/24/2013 3:07:53 AM
NO RATINGS
Max, thank you for this very interesting subject!

As a potential buyer of PCB Tool software my three criteria are: 1. How easily can the user accomplish things swiftly with this piece of software? i e ease of use 2. What can it do in terms of design complexity? 3. What does it cost?

None of your graphs explicitly cover point 3.

Buy having "corporate complexity" in your diagrams, you partly answer one aspect of point 1., collaboration in a team. However it doesn't cover ease of use for the individual user nor for a team.


I find your second diagram easiest to intuitively read because the axes are labeled and easy to understand. Diagram three is interesting, but requires a lot of text to explain; for example, what is meant by "high end" "low end" "basic" and "mainstream?"

I would suggest using several diagrams, and not try to say it all with only one.





betajet
User Rank
CEO
Two comments
betajet   10/23/2013 7:22:46 PM
NO RATINGS
Comment #1:  By "Design Complexity", do you mean the complexity of the design you are trying to process using the tool, or do you mean the complexity of the tool's user interface design?  My experience has been that the more expensive the tool (e.g., you have to be an "enterprise" to afford it), the more complex the tool's user interface and the harder it is to use the tool.  JMO/YMMV  Also, each generation of the tool becomes harder to use as more features clutter up the menus and functionality, until it becomes pretty much unusable.  According to Alan Perlis, this happens with all software: "Every program eventually becomes rococo, and then rubble."  But it seems to happen faster with CAD tools.

Comment #2:  When I started looking at the graphs, my rather quirky mind immediately thought of the scene in Dead Poets Society (1989) in which Robin Williams draws a graph on the blackboard to show a systematic way of rating poetry.  He has a mischievous look on his face while a student reads out loud the introduction to their poetry text:
If the poem's score for Perfection is plotted along the horizontal of a graph, and its Importance is plotted on the vertical, then calculating the total area of the poem yields the measure of its Greatness.

Williams steps back to show a graph labeled P.I.G.  He then tells them this attempt to analyze poetry is utter nonsense (or a word to that effect) and tells them to tear the introduction out of the book, which they then do.

To me, a fine piece of software is like a great work of poetry or music.  OTOH, a lot of CAD software is purely pedestrian, so perhaps 2-D analysis may be of some value.

Max The Magnificent
User Rank
Blogger
Re: More than two categories
Max The Magnificent   10/23/2013 4:20:10 PM
NO RATINGS
@Garcia: About the graphs, I prefer the two first ones, but I'm not able to choose one. I feel that the actual "curves" will arise once we place some tools between the axes!

That's the part I'm looking forward to :-)   I have a cunning plan in mind -- keep watching PCB Designline for my next blog on thsi topic...

 

Max The Magnificent
User Rank
Blogger
Re: More than two categories
Max The Magnificent   10/23/2013 4:18:23 PM
NO RATINGS
@Elizabeth: I like your categories of Individual-Level, Small-Business-Level, and Enterprise-Level

Max The Magnificent
User Rank
Blogger
Re: More than two categories
Max The Magnificent   10/23/2013 4:17:04 PM
NO RATINGS
@Elizabeth: Currently, I'm using DipTrace which seems to be a good tool for the price although I'd be interested in a review of DesignSpark PCB.

I'll trade you -- if you write a review on DipTrace, I'll get someone else to pen a piece on DesignSpark PCB.

Garcia-Lasheras
User Rank
Blogger
Re: More than two categories
Garcia-Lasheras   10/23/2013 3:07:12 PM
NO RATINGS
@elisabethsimon: "we use an enterprise level Mentor suite with a separate PCB design group that does the board layout"

Splitting the PCB design flow in this way is a common practice. In fact, I know some companies that don't do PCB layout, but only schematic capture. Then, they send the schematic to speciallized third-party teams that provide PCB layout services.

About the graphs, I prefer the two first ones, but I'm not able to choose one. I feel that the actual "curves" will arise once we place some tools between the axes!

elizabethsimon
User Rank
CEO
More than two categories
elizabethsimon   10/23/2013 2:25:12 PM
NO RATINGS
I like the view as a continuium (second graph) although the first would work if you put a third category in the middle.

For category names:

Individual level (one person working alone on simple designs)

Small business level (small group working on medium complexity designs)

Enterprise level (large company doing complex designs)

Of interest to me would be PCB tools priced for individual or small business with the capibilities to do more complex designs.

In my day job, we use an enterprise level Mentor suite with a separate PCB design group that does the board layout. On evenings and weekends I use lower cost tools to do simple to medium complexity designs. Currently, I'm using DipTrace which seems to be a good tool for the price although I'd be interested in a review of DesignSpark PCB.

 

 

<<   <   Page 3 / 3


Top Comments of the Week
Flash Poll
Like Us on Facebook

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
<b><a href=Betajet">

The Circle – The Future's Imperfect in the Present Tense
Betajet
5 comments
The Circle, a satirical, dystopian novel published in 2013 by San Francisco-based writer Dave Eggers, is about a large, very powerful technology company that combines aspects of Google, ...

Max Maxfield

Recommended Reads From the Engineer's Bookshelf
Max Maxfield
27 comments
I'm not sure if I read more than most folks or not, but I do I know that I spend quite a lot of time reading. I hate to be idle, so I always have a book or two somewhere about my person -- ...

Martin Rowe

Make This Engineering Museum a Reality
Martin Rowe
Post a comment
Vincent Valentine is a man on a mission. He wants to make the first house to ever have a telephone into a telephone museum. Without help, it may not happen.

Rich Quinnell

Making the Grade in Industrial Design
Rich Quinnell
16 comments
As every developer knows, there are the paper specifications for a product design, and then there are the real requirements. The paper specs are dry, bland, and rigidly numeric, making ...

Special Video Section
The LT8640 is a 42V, 5A synchronous step-down regulator ...
The LTC2000 high-speed DAC has low noise and excellent ...
How do you protect the load and ensure output continues to ...
General-purpose DACs have applications in instrumentation, ...
Linear Technology demonstrates its latest measurement ...
10:29
Demos from Maxim Integrated at Electronica 2014 show ...
Bosch CEO Stefan Finkbeiner shows off latest combo and ...
STMicroelectronics demoed this simple gesture control ...
Keysight shows you what signals lurk in real-time at 510MHz ...
TE Connectivity's clear-plastic, full-size model car shows ...
Why culture makes Linear Tech a winner.
Recently formed Architects of Modern Power consortium ...
Specially modified Corvette C7 Stingray responds to ex Indy ...
Avago’s ACPL-K30T is the first solid-state driver qualified ...
NXP launches its line of multi-gate, multifunction, ...
Doug Bailey, VP of marketing at Power Integrations, gives a ...
See how to ease software bring-up with DesignWare IP ...
DesignWare IP Prototyping Kits enable fast software ...
This video explores the LT3086, a new member of our LDO+ ...
In today’s modern electronic systems, the need for power ...