Design Con 2015
Breaking News
Comments
Oldest First | Newest First | Threaded View
Page 1 / 4   >   >>
Matthieu Wipliez
User Rank
Manager
Hint: RTL sucks.
Matthieu Wipliez   8/13/2014 6:30:29 AM
I'm happy to see that FPGAs are finding their ways into datacenters for unexpected uses (I mean compared to their traditional uses), but at the same time it was far from being the first choice "we looked at software, then GPUs and then FPGAs". And why?

Because "The FPGA tools are too slow, there are too many warnings and not great debugging -- but that's not new." Combine that with the fact that RTL is still horrible to write (and whether you use old or new HDLs does not change a lot IMO), and they had to come up with "a middle ground between C++ and RTL where people can program". Interesting, it sounds a lot like Cx.

Of course if Microsoft and Baidu had known about ngDesign, they could have used an Eclipse-based IDE featuring on-the-fly error checking and fast code generation. We have plans for a fast simulator + debugger, Microsof and Baidu feel free to contact us!

cd2012
User Rank
Manager
Using C++
cd2012   8/13/2014 11:22:31 AM
NO RATINGS
Both FPGA vendors offer OpenCL which allows programmers to use C++.  I wonder why this team didn't use it.  Was it not mature enough at the time?  Or, did OpenCL not hinder a performance gain?

TanjB
User Rank
Rookie
Re: Using C++
TanjB   8/13/2014 2:15:43 PM
NO RATINGS
At this stage more of the engineering effort revolves around system compatibility with the data center environment (power, form factor, networking, etc.), and scheduling use of resources distributed across a network of FPGAs, than the relatively solved problem of programming individual FPGAs.

AZskibum
User Rank
CEO
Re: Using C++
AZskibum   8/13/2014 8:54:37 PM
NO RATINGS
I would be curious to see the trade study between using FPGAs and using GPUs with either CUDA or OpenCL to accelerate the datacenter. As for the C++ interface, that's really nice for us old-timers, but show me a C++ programmer who is under 40-something and I'll buy you a Starbucks coffee :)

SwanOnChips
User Rank
Freelancer
Microsoft did not simply implement SW in HW
SwanOnChips   8/14/2014 2:17:25 AM
What intrigued me about Microsoft's use of the FPGA's is they implemented ranking of the web search results NOT with HW implementation of SW, but with 60 SOFT processor cores on the FPGA! Since each core handles 4 threads, that's a total of 240 threads. (Though the micrograph in their slide pictures only 48 cores (8 clusters of 6 cores)

rick merritt
User Rank
Author
Re: Microsoft did not simply implement SW in HW
rick merritt   8/14/2014 1:15:22 PM
NO RATINGS
@Swan: Thanks for calling out that detail.

It's amazing to me how these MS Research folks started with looking for sw to accelerate Bing and followed a path all the way to developing FPGA cores and tools.

rick merritt
User Rank
Author
Re: Using C++
rick merritt   8/14/2014 1:16:14 PM
NO RATINGS
@cd2012: Great question. I'll ask Andrew to weigh in!

KarlS01
User Rank
Manager
"We gave them a middle ground between C++ and RTL where people can program,"
KarlS01   8/14/2014 5:23:54 PM
NO RATINGS
The processor is multi-core shared ALU design as opposed to conventional FPGA design.  It is also multi-threaded so the speedup is due to multi-thread execution rather than traditional FPGA pipe-lined computation. 

This may mean that a different design approach is needed.  Technology evolution may have made the traditional approach of maximizing fmax obsolete.

SwanOnChips
User Rank
Freelancer
Re: Using C++
SwanOnChips   8/14/2014 8:20:38 PM
NO RATINGS
@cd2012: My comment alludes to the answer. It's because they did not implement SW as HW which is what the FPGA suppliers will do with OpenCL. For whatever reason Microsoft chose to implement many-core SOFT processors on the FPGA's, so the FPGA's are still running SW, albeit multi-threaded.

SwanOnChips
User Rank
Freelancer
Re: Using C++
SwanOnChips   8/14/2014 8:23:10 PM
NO RATINGS
@Merritt, now that I have answered the question for @cd2012, the real question I think to ask Microsoft is embedded in my answer. Want to ask them that?

Page 1 / 4   >   >>


Flash Poll
Top Comments of the Week
Like Us on Facebook
EE Times on Twitter
EE Times Twitter Feed

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
EE Life
Frankenstein's Fix, Teardowns, Sideshows, Design Contests, Reader Content & More
Max Maxfield

Want to Present a Paper at ESC Boston 2015?
Max Maxfield
8 comments
I tell you, I need more hours in each day. If I was having any more fun, there would have to be two of me to handle it all. For example, I just heard that I'm going to be both a speaker ...

Martin Rowe

No 2014 Punkin Chunkin, What Will You Do?
Martin Rowe
Post a comment
American Thanksgiving is next week, and while some people watch (American) football all day, the real competition on TV has become Punkin Chunkin. But there will be no Punkin Chunkin on TV ...

Rich Quinnell

Making the Grade in Industrial Design
Rich Quinnell
12 comments
As every developer knows, there are the paper specifications for a product design, and then there are the real requirements. The paper specs are dry, bland, and rigidly numeric, making ...

Martin Rowe

Book Review: Controlling Radiated Emissions by Design
Martin Rowe
1 Comment
Controlling Radiated Emissions by Design, Third Edition, by Michel Mardiguian. Contributions by Donald L. Sweeney and Roger Swanberg. List price: $89.99 (e-book), $119 (hardcover).