United Business Media EE Times


Search

HOMEMARKET INTELLIGENCE UNITFORUMSDESIGNNEW PRODUCTSCAREERSBLOGSCONTACTEVENTSSIGN UP!RSSMost Popular contentTrusted Sources

 

Micron's suit accuses Rambus of trying to trick DRAM makers
Complaint says industry being coerced with 'exorbitant royalties' in licensing negotiations
Print this article Email this article Reprints RSS Digital Edition

EBN


WASHINGTON -- Charging Rambus Inc. with trying to "coerce exorbitant royalties" from the DRAM industry, Micron Technology Inc.'s antitrust lawsuit will determine the validity of key patents that serve as the foundation for much of the computing world's memory requirements.

The suit, filed on Monday in U.S. District Court in Delaware, seeks to invalidate patents Rambus holds pertaining to a synchronous interface used in billions of memory devices, processors, and core-logic chipsets and seeks unspecified damages from Rambus as well as treble punitive damages allowed under antitrust law.

Boise, Idaho-based Micron alleges that Rambus is unduly coercing makers of SDRAM and double-data-rate SDRAM chips as part of a strategy "to file lawsuits against those manufacturers who do not agree to Rambus' non-negotiable license terms." Micron also accuses Rambus of tricking DRAM makers by keeping secret its development plans while collecting information in industry standards meetings with other suppliers.

Reacting to the suit today, Rambus officials denied charges of antitrust behavior in the company's negotiations of new licensing pacts (see today's story).

Mountain View, Calif.-based Rambus is the developer the Direct Rambus DRAM interface, which is competing with synchronous DDR memories in new computer systems, but early this year the company also claimed rights to technology that serves as the basis for SDRAM designs. The company has negotiated agreements with Oki, Toshiba, and Hitachi, but recently filed suit against Infineon Technologies AG of Munich when negotiations broke down. That lawsuit is pending in a Richmond, Va., federal court (see Aug. 11 story).

According to Micron, Rambus is seeking to gain an unfair competitive advantage for Direct Rambus DRAM technology -- which to date has been more expensive than SDRAM to manufacture -- and as much as "admitted that it intends to charge more for licenses to SDRAM products that it views as a threat to its own RDRAM technology," said a copy of the suit.

In its response to the suit, Rambus issued a statement today saying it had initiated negotiations with Micron to license intellectual property for use in SDRAM and DDR SDRAMs. Rambus said Micron chose to litigate rather than negotiate.

However, in its suit Micron said it took legal action because it was expecting to be sued by Rambus. Micron suggested that it was being targeted by Rambus because it has been a prime advocate of DDR SDRAM -- even as it has continued to develop Direct RDRAM under an existing license. A Micron spokesman said despite the complaint, the chip maker will continue with plans to validate its Rambus prototypes.

The move follows word earlier this year that an ad hoc group of DRAM vendors was considering filing a suit with the Federal Trade Commission. Micron -- which was among the member companies said to be pondering the action -- declined to comment about possible plans to take its case to the FTC.

The looming court battle is expected to hinge on legal precedent set by Dell Computer Corp., which was found in 1996 by a federal court to have sought out royalties for patents that the company helped draft as part of open industry standards deliberations. A similar case involving Wang Laboratories was settled out of court, but is also expected to play a part in Micron's legal attack plan.

Specifically, Micron is claiming that industry procedures required Rambus to disclose any pending patents related to the development of a synchronous interface when the topic was discussed from 1991 through 1996 during open JEDEC standards forums. By failing to disclose its development plans, Rambus in effect obtained information, which it then subverted to preempt competitors, Micron is charging.

"Instead of offering a royalty-free or other reasonable license when it was obligated to do so, Rambus waited until the standards had been adopted and the industry had spent billions of dollars in reliance on the standards," the suit alleges.

The same argument was presented earlier this year when Hitachi Ltd. fell under Rambus' legal crosshairs, but has never endured a legal test. Hitachi settled with Rambus before the case was brought to trial.






  Free Subscription to EE Times
First Name Last Name
Company Name Title
Email address
  Click here for your Free Subscription to EETimes Europe
 
CAREER CENTER
Looking for a new job?
SEARCH JOBS
SPONSOR

RECENT JOB POSTINGS
CAREER NEWS
DoD Recognizes University Scientists For Basic Research
Annual awards to university faculty to conduct next-generation research projects were announced this week by the Defense Department.

For more great jobs, career related news, features and services, please visit EETimes' Career Center.



All White Papers »   

  Around Silicon Strategies

10 emerging technologies to watch: EE Times has compiled a list of emerging technologies that we think will be worth watching out for in 2010. Biofeedback or thought-control of electronics are among the contenders. More...

Hot applications in 2010: We've compiled a list of 10 technology applications you should watch for in 2010, ranging from e-book readers to 3-D TVs. We examine the features that make these apps so compelling as well unresolved issues. More...

Top 25 predictions for semis in 2010: 2010 is just beginning to unfold in the electronics industry. Looking into our crystal ball, we have released our own chip forecasts--and other predictions--for 2010. More...

Seven things to fix in 2010: The editors of EE Times came up with their own informal list of things we hope engineers fix in 2010, spanning everything from nano-lithography to space travel. What do you want to see get done this year? More...

'09 moves that are shaping the future: This was a brutal year, but the industry gets a nod for showing grace under fire. Here's our Top 10 guide to the coming year, illustrating what to expect in 2010. More...

10 CEOs out in 2009: It's been a tough year for the global electronics industry and CEOs. We survey the dismissal of 10 industry CEOs during the first three quarters of 2009 and what's ahead for the rest of the year. More...

Notable women in microelectronics: There is no better time than a global economic recession to examine the keys to successful corporate governance. So, EE Times has compiled an international list that celebrates women who are business and technology leaders in semis. More...

EE Times updates Silicon 60: Seventeen companies have been added to the lastest version of our Silicon 60 list of emerging startups. Forty-three companies survived as emerging companies that are still worth watching. More...

 
Education and
Learning


Learn Now:












Home | About | Editorial Calendar | Feedback | Subscriptions | Newsletter | Media Kit | Contact | Reprints|  RSS|   Digital|  Mobile
Network Websites
International
Network Features




All materials on this site Copyright © 2010 TechInsights, a Division of United Business Media LLC All rights reserved.
Privacy Statement | Terms of Service | About