United Business Media EE Times


Search

HOMEMARKET INTELLIGENCE UNITFORUMSDESIGNNEW PRODUCTSCAREERSBLOGSCONTACTEVENTSSIGN UP!RSSMost Popular contentTrusted Sources

 

UPDATED: Jury finds Rambus committed fraud
Print this article Email this article Reprints RSS Digital Edition

EBN


RICHMOND, Va. - A federal court jury here Wednesday afternoon found Rambus Inc. had committed fraud by failing to disclose its synchronous patent applications to the industry JEDEC standards body.

The jury ordered Rambus to pay $3.5 million in punitive damages to Infineon Technologies AG, which Rambus had sued for alleged patent infringement.

The damage amount, however, will likely be reduced to as low as $350,000 due to a Virginia state law capping the level of punitive awards.

In a separate count, the jury Wednesday determined that Rambus had not violated RICO anti-racketing law as a result of its patent application silence at JEDEC.

Infineon attorneys told Federal Judge Robert Payne Wednesday that they will file a motion, based on the jury's verdict of fraud, to have the Rambus patents declared unenforceable against the German chip maker.

If the judge made such a ruling, it could be cited as a precedent in the two other pending Rambus synchronous patent cases involving Micron Technology and Hynix Semiconductor (formerly Hyundai Electronics).

Infineon attorneys told EBN they are seeking the ruling as a safeguard in the event an appellate court overrules Judge Payne's decision that Infineon didn't infringe Rambus' patents.

Last week, Infineon was cleared of infringing Rambus' synchronous patent infringement, when Judge Payne ruled that the chip maker's SDRAM and DDR chips didn't have a multiplexed memory bus that the Rambus patents require.

Avo Kanadjian, Rambus vice president of worldwide marketing, declined to comment immediately after the jury verdict, asking to have further time to consider the decision.

Rambus issued a statement that it plans to immediately appeal today's verdict. In addition, Rambus said it will file post-trial briefs with the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia to set aside today's verdict.

"We are obviously disappointed in today's verdict and will immediately appeal," said Geoff Tate, CEO of Rambus, in the released statement. "The innovations at issue are Rambus inventions, and the evidence presented at trial made it clear that Infineon knew all along that they were Rambus inventions."

"I attended the whole trial and continue to believe that Infineon's JEDEC charges are completely baseless. Rambus abided by JEDEC's rules despite the fact that these rules have been shown to be confusing, conflicting, poorly communicated and generally not complied with by other JEDEC members.

"Today's verdict, if allowed to stand, poses a serious threat to all technology companies that try to protect their inventions through our intellectual property laws. It puts innovators at risk of forfeiting their intellectual property rights by simply attending meetings of a standard setting committee."

Rambus has already appealed Judge Payne's earlier summary judgment throwing out infringment claims.

The fraud verdict is the first public judgment against Rambus' silence on its synchronous patent applications during four years of participation in the industry JEDEC panel drafting an SDRAM open standard.

Sherry Garber, vice president of Semico Research, Phoenix, said the jury verdict of fraud "has to be a great embarrassment for Rambus as well as having a negative financial impact." She said the finding of fraud is a serious matter for any company, especially for Rambus as it seeks to push its core Direct RDRAM and collect royalties of SDRAMs and DDR.

Micron and Hynix separately have also charged Rambus with fraud in its JEDEC behavior.

Rambus had argued that it disclosed its basic Rambus DRAM patent which included features that later were added to its synchronous DRAM applications.

In addition to the legal setbacks to Rambus, the Richmond trial for the first time disclosed formerly confidential synchronous licensing details with eight chip makers that impact Rambus' royalty revenue stream.

This week Infineon attorneys revealed that Samsung Electronics Co. can stop paying SDRAM and DDR royalties to Rambus if a court in any geographic region of the world determines that any company does not infringe the synchronous patents.

It was also disclosed for the first time that Rambus was charging each of its eight licensees, including Samsung, a 3.5% royalty of DDR sales, as well as 0.75% royalty on singel data rate SDRAMs.

Judge Payne told the jury Tuesday that if it determined that Rambus committed an actual fraud, it had the option of awarding punitive damages against the firm.






  Free Subscription to EE Times
First Name Last Name
Company Name Title
Email address
  Click here for your Free Subscription to EETimes Europe
 
CAREER CENTER
Looking for a new job?
SEARCH JOBS
SPONSOR

RECENT JOB POSTINGS
CAREER NEWS
Anita Borg Institute Honors 3 Women
Group Honors Three Women For Contributions To Tech

For more great jobs, career related news, features and services, please visit EETimes' Career Center.



All White Papers »   

  Around Silicon Strategies

10 emerging technologies to watch: EE Times has compiled a list of emerging technologies that we think will be worth watching out for in 2010. Biofeedback or thought-control of electronics are among the contenders. More...

Hot applications in 2010: We've compiled a list of 10 technology applications you should watch for in 2010, ranging from e-book readers to 3-D TVs. We examine the features that make these apps so compelling as well unresolved issues. More...

Top 25 predictions for semis in 2010: 2010 is just beginning to unfold in the electronics industry. Looking into our crystal ball, we have released our own chip forecasts--and other predictions--for 2010. More...

Seven things to fix in 2010: The editors of EE Times came up with their own informal list of things we hope engineers fix in 2010, spanning everything from nano-lithography to space travel. What do you want to see get done this year? More...

'09 moves that are shaping the future: This was a brutal year, but the industry gets a nod for showing grace under fire. Here's our Top 10 guide to the coming year, illustrating what to expect in 2010. More...

10 CEOs out in 2009: It's been a tough year for the global electronics industry and CEOs. We survey the dismissal of 10 industry CEOs during the first three quarters of 2009 and what's ahead for the rest of the year. More...

Notable women in microelectronics: There is no better time than a global economic recession to examine the keys to successful corporate governance. So, EE Times has compiled an international list that celebrates women who are business and technology leaders in semis. More...

EE Times updates Silicon 60: Seventeen companies have been added to the lastest version of our Silicon 60 list of emerging startups. Forty-three companies survived as emerging companies that are still worth watching. More...

 
Education and
Learning


Learn Now:












Home | About | Editorial Calendar | Feedback | Subscriptions | Newsletter | Media Kit | Contact | Reprints|  RSS|   Digital|  Mobile
Network Websites
International
Network Features




All materials on this site Copyright © 2010 EE Times Group, a Division of United Business Media LLC All rights reserved.
Privacy Statement | Terms of Service | About